The greatest directors in Hollywood (part one)
By Jonathan Peters

Geek fandom cried out in protest last week, as Edgar Wright quit Marvel’s Ant Man after alleged behind-the-scenes pressure from the studio. The upset is understandable. Very few directors working today craft such distinctive films that are adored by critics and fans alike, movies which are anticipated as events, that can generate excitement simply by the attachment of a particular director, and a proportionate outpouring of emotion when they then depart for whatever reason.
For example, if Stephen Frears (High Fidelity, Philomena) exits a production, it’s a shame as he’s a perfectly competent filmmaker, but none of his films possess the unique stamp, the singularity of vision, that is characteristic of Wright, and the select bunch of directors compiled in this list.
NB: to merit inclusion, the director has to still make regular, acclaimed films. Francis Ford Coppola may continue to live and breathe, for instance, but he arguably hasn’t produced anything vital since 1979’s Apocalypse Now.

20. Ridley Scott
Not always the most consistent director (see The Counsellor), but when he’s on form, Ridley Scott can blow audiences away. Few filmmakers can lay claim to having traversed so many genres and created a defining classic in each – from Thelma and Louise (buddy movie), to Alien (horror), Blade Runner (sci-fi), and epic (Gladiator), Scott deserves to be recognised as a national treasure. Hopefully next year’s  Exodus, with Christian Bale and Aaron Paul, will see the veteran director back to his very best.
19. Sofia Coppola
Whilst The Bling Ring was last year’s most underrated satire, eviscerating the shallowness at the heart of American celebrity culture, Coppola’s true masterpiece is Lost in Translation, a heartfelt meditation on loneliness and disconnection in modern society. Boasting jaw-droppingly beautiful cinematography of Japan, Bill Murray’s sad, revelatory performance, and a star-making turn from Scarlett Johansson, the film is essential viewing.

18. Tim Burton
No Tim Burton movie wants for atmosphere, his dark, gothic aesthetic providing a backdrop for some of the most imaginative fantasies ever conceived on celluloid. For every slight misfire, a classic like Beetlejuice or Edward Scissorhands comes along, featuring striking imagery, offbeat black comedy, and emotionally resonant stories (plus usually some acting from Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter).
17. David Fincher
Out of all the directors on this list, David Fincher’s career probably had the least promising start, with the franchise-crippling critical failure that was Alien 3. He managed to break free from studio shackles however with gripping thriller Seven, and every film since has showcased his kinetic, moody and intelligent style. Fincher has a knack for rendering great material from unpromising sources – Chuck Palanhiuk’s Fight Club, the literary equivalent of a video nasty and one of the worst bestselling novels ever, became a modern classic in his hands, and with The Social Network he somehow turned a movie about Facebook into something Oscar-worthy.

16.  Hayao Miyazaki
The recently retired director left possibly the greatest legacy to the animation world since Walt Disney, with Studio Ghibli producing some of the most beautiful-looking films ever made – every painstakingly-drawn frame could be a watercolour painting. In films such as Princess Mononoke and Spirited Away, his adept storytelling abilities managed to make unfamiliar elements of Japanese culture and history universally accessible.
15. Spike Lee
The best Spike Lee films explode with passion and raw energy – 195-minute epic Malcolm X is the most visceral biopic ever committed to screen, whilst Do The Right Thing is an intense racial drama that builds to a crescendo of violence over one hot, New York summer day. Lee is a potent voice of dissent in mainstream Hollywood, when not constrained by studio interference (Oldboy), attacking prejudice and injustice with poetic, provocative filmmaking.

14. Alfonso CuarĂłn
Usurping Martin Scorsese on his throne, the new master of the long take achieved deserved Oscar glory with hit space thriller Gravity. Cuarón developed new cinematographic methods to capture the most authentic depiction of inner space since Stanley Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey. The opening, 15-minute shot is matched only by Sandra Bullock’s powerfully-filmed first steps on land at the end of the film, and the devastating car assault scene in Children of Men.
13. Spike Jonze
Jackass producer, part-time music video helmer, and estimably the most daringly original director in the industry. Being John Malkovich uses the idea of a portal existing into John Malkovich’s brain as just the starting point from which to hang countless crazy and intriguing concepts, although the film is controlled and easy to follow thanks to Jonze’s directorial skill. Adaptation manages to take meta to the extreme without coming across as overly condescending or ironic, whilst her is the definitive contemporary romance, exploring our relationships with exponentially more advanced technology in a manner which is mature, restrained and compelling.

12. Steve McQueen
There’s no surprise that Steve McQueen won the Turner Prize before he turned to directing. Each shot is expertly filmed for maximum visual power – from Shame’s quick cuts between Michael Fassbender’s traumatic sexual experiences and their aftermath, to the framing of the ominous red wheels of the slave ship and Solomon’s burning letter in 12 Years A Slave. His films do not shy away from difficult themes – 2011’s Shame dealt with sex addiction in a far more subtle way than Lars Von Trier’s grotesquely marketed, Rammstein-soundtracked Nymphomaniac, and this year’s Oscar Best Film 12 Years A Slave dug up an often neglected, shameful period in American history.
11. Edgar Wright
The inspiration for this list, Edgar Wright brings a relentless energy sorely lacking in modern comedy, where the camera normally lingers statically on characters rather than extracting humour through the cinematography. Rom-zom-com Shaun of the Dead was the finest British comedy since Four Weddings and a Funeral, and the best spoof since the golden age of Airplane! Hot Fuzz spliced together a west country murder mystery and a glossy action thriller to uproarious effect, Scott Pilgrim Versus the World was the greatest video game adaptation not actually based on a video game, and The World’s End imbued the roles of long-time collaborators Simon Pegg and Nick Frost with unexpected pathos in its consideration of aging and the effects of nostalgia. Whatever the director turns his hand to next, he is sure to strike gold.
Check back for Part Two, featuring the top ten, coming soon…
