Gretel and the Dark: reviewed
Since the fall of Hitler’s Third Reich in 1945 there has been an outpouring of Holocaust literature.  Gretel and the Dark by Eliza Granville is a children’s book that belongs to this extensive genre, but only by a technicality, as this novel reaches the depths of human perception and experience through torment that many of this genre rarely do.
Gretel and the Dark flits between 1899 fin-de-siècle Vienna, governed by Mayor Lueger, determined to distract from the cities’ incapability to deal with the ceaseless flow of Eastern European migrants by encouraging an anti-Semitic movement, and what the reader later learns to be Nazi Germany, specifically Ravensbruck concentration camp. Granville’s choice of setting is not coincidental, as she is able to utilise the dystopian atmosphere of the reluctantly crumbling Austro-Hungarian Empire and the racially driven regime of Nazi Germany to enhance the theme of fairytales and the “other” within the novel. Moreover, the author’s focus on two distinct time periods hostile to the Jewish people adds the idea of their extended suffering that many novels of this genre lack.
Gretel and the Dark, layered expertly, also shifts between two narratives of seemingly unrelated characters between chapters. First, we are transported to Austria where prominent Doktor Josef Breuer is trying to escape the scandals of his past, only to stumble upon his most fascinating case to date when his gardener finds a beautiful young woman, Lilie, near a lunatic asylum, naked, beaten and insisting that she was created as a machine. The Doktor cannot understand where she has come from, and in his desperate search for answers about his patient, the reader is taken down some of Vienna’s darkest alleyways, and we begin to wonder what the purpose of Lilie’s stay is with the Doktor.
Then the novel jumps to Krysta, a spoilt young girl who lives with her father just outside the walls of an “animal people” zoo, where she can hear the screeches and howls of where he works from her window. Krysta’s narrative often wanders back to her previous life with Grete the housemaid, who kept a horde of fantastical fairytales in her head, and narrates her present day battles through the medium of these fantasies. The inclusion of fairytales within the novel is a reflection of how Germanic fairytales were used as a basis in Nazi Germany’s propaganda, distorting them so that the victims were Aryan children and the villains society’s degenerates.
What makes Krysta’s narrative so unique is her negotiation of the sinister world around her through the fairytales she was once taught. This adds a dimension of innocence to her narration, and emphasises her characterisation and suffering as a child. This is especially apparent towards the end of the novel when Granville omits the grisly details of Krysta’s experiences, instead presenting them through a series of Grete’s fragmented stories, repeated over and over, just like Krysta’s harrowing experiences.
The progression of the plot of Gretel and the Dark does not correspond with the story itself, unless the reader picks up on the series of clues that the author leaves embedded in both Lilie’s and Krysta’s chapters, just like the breadcrumbs that Hansel and Gretel leave behind them on the forest path. Granville uses these subtle hints to lead the reader down numerous different routes that the plot could take, which makes the revelation at the end all the more exciting. It is refreshing to read a novel aimed at young people that has such an unpredictable and beautifully concealed plot twist, for this I think Granville should be commended. Furthermore, because the reader does not know Gretel and the Dark is a Holocaust novel until the ending, the pain that Krysta endures seems much more isolated and personal to her. This adds a very human and raw dimension to the novel, to feel one small girl’s pain so intensely, and yet to know that this was not a unique case.
The nightmarish quality of the novel is offset slightly by its scientific psychoanalytical focus, as the use of the narrative and storytelling are often used in therapy to tease out buried memories and to make sense of traumatic pasts. The story is also jolted slightly by snippets of the German language throughout in character’s speech and in retelling fairytales, although adding to the authenticity and richness of the novel, it can be overwhelming when combined with the fast pace of the plot at times.
Gretel and the Dark is certainly not a children’s book, but the way in which Granville readdresses such an infamous topic is stylistically delicate and thematically perceptive. The novel deserves to be placed on the mantel alongside other greats of the genre such as The Reader and The Boy in Striped Pyjamas. I urge you to read it.
Gretel and the Dark by Eliza Granville was published by Hamish Hamilton 6 February 2014
Cover image courtesy of Penguin

