The Fingleton Review: a blueprint for destruction
By Alexander Ringsmith
It seems that at any given point this government has taken the opportunity to stir up anger against itself, alienating all of its different voter bases in equal measure. While in many cases this could be put down to pure ineptitude, there are two areas where a supposedly progressive party such as Labour seem to diverge from their founding principles. One of these is already well known, and concerns the very public debates around immigration where the government seem eager to follow in the footsteps of far-right parties such as Reform. However, it is nature and environmental protections that have experienced the most excessive level of contempt since Labour entered office, and within the past few months this attitude towards the natural world has been highlighted by a government-commissioned review into nuclear regulation.
While initially the Nuclear Regulatory Review 2025 gives the impression of a dry review looking into rather tedious planning considerations regarding nuclear energy, the recommendations it provided are shocking for anyone with even a slight appreciation of nature or wildlife, and have the potential to be deeply damaging. The most severe recommendation to emerge from the report was that developers could ignore the need to assess the environmental impact of their project simply by paying a fee to Natural England, the government body responsible for the care of the natural world. This could give free rein for infrastructure projects to devastate the landscape and wildlife, even within National Parks. As is so common with many government-issued reports, the taskforce that carried out the Nuclear Regulatory Review 2025 was led by an economist, John Fingleton – alongside nuclear scientists and development professionals. Quite remarkably, however, the taskforce which has been instructed to look into environmental regulations didn’t hold a single expert in the natural environment.
The scapegoating of nature and the dismissal of people’s genuine concerns is an affront to democracy, not just a fringe issue
This is by no means an isolated incident, as the government’s so-called ‘growth agenda’ has consistently taken an aggressively accusatory stance based on prejudiced and inaccurate thinking, and you have to ask yourself who this ‘growth’ is for. Since Labour came to power 18 months ago, its track record on the environment represents a graveyard of broken promises. The manifesto asserted the party’s commitment to sustainable planning and development, but then swiftly backtracked to allow profit-focused developers to build without consideration for nature, and weakening commitments to Biodiversity Net Gain (the strategy to increase nature alongside new homes). Its promise to promote regenerative farming has yet to materialise, and instead there has been a move towards maximising food production at the expense of farming that supports and works with the natural world.
However, the ‘development vs nature’ fight that the government champions is an abstraction, as it is not only possible to encourage sustainable housebuilding while regenerating natural areas, but there are many examples of when it has been put in practice. The most significant thing to consider is that the government could likely reach its housebuilding target of 1.5 million homes by encouraging development on brownfield sites (sites that have already been built on but are now disused) which would also aid in their goal of urban regeneration. There are a multitude of existing and prospective examples to choose from, but the Phoenix project in the Sussex town of Lewes is particularly inspirational and is what first got me interested. It is a proposal that would see the redevelopment of an abandoned industrial site on the River Ouse for 700 homes, a third of which would be affordable, and was designed in consultation with the local community based on environmental principles. Where it becomes necessary for greenfield sites to be used, high density developments (such as affordable mansion blocks that utilise early 20th century designs) that work in conjunction with both nature and existing communities should be applied. The scapegoating of nature and the dismissal of people’s genuine concerns is an affront to democracy, not just a fringe issue, and the aggressive tone the government uses ignores the fact that when communities are involved in housing projects, they are typically delivered faster, cheaper, and are more beneficial to all.
Perhaps the most perplexing part of this entire farce is the fact that, for the most part, the public actively supports the regeneration of nature and environmental protections. Britain is a country with a reputation for its love of nature, and a recent poll commissioned by the Wildlife Trusts suggests that the public think that politicians are failing on river pollution (78%), nature loss (71%), climate change (69%), and community access to nature (65%). In spite of this, the government continues to pursue an agenda that is in complete contradiction to the widespread support for the environment, which will only damage their own poll ratings. We can only hope that public pressure will make them see the urgent need to protect the British landscape and wildlife, and that they will recognise the importance of environmental protections and work with communities instead of favouring profit-minded developers.
Image: Petr Adamek via Wikimedia Commons

