Public service, private peril: the fight for the BBC

By Alexander Ringsmith

I don’t think it’s much of an exaggeration to say that nearly everyone in the UK has had some form of interaction with the BBC, and its impact worldwide should not be too readily forgotten either. While the corporation has garnered a reputation for not moving with the times – it has remained a vital centrepiece for creativity and stability in a world of division and cuts to cultural funding. 

It is sometimes hard to wrap your head around just how vast the BBC is, the news service alone employs over 5,500 journalists, and reaches over 400 million people through the BBC World Service, making it undeniably the largest broadcast news operation in the world. However, the BBC is far more than just news, and is intrinsically woven into the cultural life of millions of people through its expansive television/streaming output, film productions, radio stations, and podcasts. No other cultural institution in the world can match the breadth of impact on a national psyche as the BBC, yet there are some who try and undermine it or claim that it is slipping into irrelevance. 

While initially it may seem baffling that anyone in Britain would actively want to destabilise the BBC, look a little deeper and the motivations become quite clear. Politicians naturally feel threatened by the corporation’s impartiality and scrutiny, and government interference has been plain to see through threats over the future of the licence fee. Business and commercial rivals also stand to benefit from a weakened BBC, as they see it as an obstacle to further profit-minded expansion. This support, however, is not static, and opinion may change if the BBC doesn’t respond to the challenges it faces. These could broadly be categorised as its outdated funding and organisational model, the overwhelming number of streaming services now on offer, and the lack of will in politics to defend the corporation’s purpose. The nation overwhelmingly supports the BBC and as such it needs to be made clear to the Government that the future of this prized institution should be in the hands of the public it serves. 

We risk losing an instrumental force for good in a world dominated by corporate greed

The other two challenges are slightly more complex in their positions, and require more top-down approaches. The extensive number of new streaming services offering millions of hours of combined viewing options presents an acute problem for an organisation that once held a monopoly over British broadcasting, and while there are undoubtedly benefits to this, there are fundamental drawbacks as well. The BBC and streaming platforms fundamentally offer different things; the former is required by law to operate a range of services for the public good and the latter are commercial entertainment companies. The financial argument is also mired in misunderstandings; Netflix without advertising costs ÂŁ155 a year with all profits going towards shareholders, while the BBC by contrast costs only marginally more at ÂŁ174 per year, and provides everything that was listed at the beginning of this article with no advertising and all funding invested into their services. Additionally, the Government’s response to this changed media landscape has been limited, and instead of taking action to champion the impartiality and creative stimulation of the BBC, it has helped to cut its funding in real terms by 30% over the past decade while at the same time claiming that the corporation isn’t doing enough to stay relevant. 

The final challenge comes in the form of the BBC’s unfit funding and organisational model, and while perhaps not as existential an issue as the threat of streaming services, fixing this issue probably has the ability to make the most impact. In its present state, the BBC is funded by a licence fee charged to households who own a TV or watch BBC iPlayer and is legally enforceable. However, this system is by no means the only way that the corporation can remain a universal service, and while the licence fee does prevent excessive government interference, parliament can still use its powers to freeze increases to the fee rate to twist the BBC’s arm. Here, I do want to highlight a potential option that I feel addresses many of the issues raised and could safeguard the BBC for the future – mutualisation. 

Mutualisation is the process of shifting ownership to users or employees for mutual benefit. It is a third way between private enterprise and nationalisation, and could involve making every citizen in the UK a member/mutual owner of the BBC. This gives users of BBC services a direct say in how the organisation is run, preventing government influence and ensuring accountability. It could also tie means-tested funding directly to the individual – providing fairer fees for the public, but a wider and more enforceable funding base for the BBC. 

While some have argued that the world has moved on from public service broadcasting, I believe now is the time when it matters more than ever before, and that a more secure BBC can only benefit the cultural life and democracy of the UK. While the BBC should rightly be held to high standards, increasingly it is suffering from blatant double-standards, and if we don’t show our support, we risk losing an instrumental force for good in a world dominated by corporate greed. It should therefore be supported by all of us as the national institution that it was founded as.

Image: Sebastiandoe5 via Wikimedia Commons