The ethics of harsh reviews
A couple of weeks ago, on one of my few social excursions, I eagerly started a conversation with an actor friend about my love of theatre reviewing. Expecting to find some common ground in our shared love of drama, he instead looked at me with peculiar distaste and quickly made an escape. I was left with something of an existential crisis. Does my tendency to ridicule weeks of hard work on the basis of a shaky first night make me a bad person? Is saying nasty things about actors and production teams really a respectable trade?
My friend was in good company, as the public perception of theatre critics is not entirely complimentary. Think of Lindsay Duncan’s portrayal of an acidic theatre critic in the Oscar winning film Birdman. “You just try to label everything,” Michael Keaton’s egotistical actor rages at her, “that’s so fuckin’ lazy.” He then sums up all theatre criticism as “crappy opinions backed up by even crappier comparisons.” Mark Twain was not a fan either: “I believe that the trade of critic in literature, music and drama is the most degraded of all trades, and that is has no real value.” Strong stuff!
So are all theatre reviewers utterly horrible people? Most certainly not. It is, in my opinion, within a critic’s remit to be critical. Maureen Dowd, a Pulitzer Prize winning book reviewer for The New York Times, wrote that “not to review books negatively is in essence to subsume book reviewing into advertising, public relations and promotion”, and the same obviously applies to theatre. Durham reviewers must risk inciting the wrath of the entire Durham Student Theatre scene to honestly evaluate under par productions.
Unfortunately, it’s not that simple, and you have to ask why we review anything at all. A reviewer could respond by saying that they act as a kind of quality control for busy theatre goers. Except, how many Durham students really read theatre reviews before heading down to The Assembly Rooms or booking tickets? Student shows generally run for around one to three days, so reviews are often published too late to influence potential audience members.
If useless for the audience, can reviews be of value for members of the production team? Surely some sort of feedback is essential after slaving away on a piece of theatre? True, but as I’m sure all actors know, sometimes theatre reviews don’t offer the most constructive feedback. A minority of thespians can’t take any negative criticism at all; see Judi Dench’s tirade against critic Charles Spencer: “I’ve always rather admired you, but now I realise you’re an absolute shit!” More often than not, however, the fault lies with the reviewer. Film critic Roger Ebert wrote a piece denouncing “the caustic critic”, who writes “first and foremost to entertain an audience”, and does not so much review a production as “call it names”.
Here I must hold my hands up in shame. Writing a negative review is a lot easier than writing about an average performance, or sometimes even a brilliant one. Humour often has to be at someone’s expense, and more often than not I see a dreadful production as an opportunity to try and be as witty as possible. In another publication, my editor happily accepted a hatchet job on a big music release, only to attract the concern of higher powers, who rather less flatteringly saw the article as a breach of the values of the website and frankly rather offensive. This is even more of a problem when my targets are not popstars, who could probably do with being taken down a notch, but students.
This doesn’t mean I’m going to abandon reviewing for a life of penitence, as I believe theatrical criticism is a worthwhile activity. A good production deserves praise from an impartial observer. For praise to mean something, a bad production must be open to an equally honest assessment.
You may ask what right I have to pass judgement on people who a) have talents that I, sadly, do not possess and b) probably know infinitely more about theatre than I do. For me, however, a reviewer is just a sample audience member, who then goes away and writes a pithy, yet honest, evaluation of the production. Yes, a lot of what theatre reviewers say is just their opinion, but opinions count for something, especially as there’s no conceivable way to provide a completely objective assessment of a performance.
It’s true, theatre reviewers can be unpleasant people, and occasionally my reviewing can be a little misguided. But any review which entirely avoids negative criticism is dishonest, and probably rather bland. Reviewers that highlight a production’s failings are not necessarily harsh. They are people who have seen some theatre, not liked it, and (unhappily for those involved) published their disappointment for others to read.
Illustration: Mariam Hayat

