The Durham Union Society image was naive

By Holly Bancroft
The Durham Union Society learnt an incredibly harsh lesson in the last few days as a huge backlash emerged over its choice of a photo of Da’esh (the self-described Islamic State) militants as a cover picture for the upcoming debate “This House believes Islam is Incompatible with the Western Liberal Democracy”. Whatever the reasons behind the original decision, the outcry ultimately stems from the fact that the Da’esh, first and foremost, cannot be used in any way to represent the religion of Islam.
It makes no logical sense to use the radical minority to generalise about the majority. However, what we are dealing with here is not even a minority sect of a religion. It is an extremist group which most Muslims utterly reject as being Islamic at all. The Da’esh offer no mercy in their approach to apostates or members of other religions. The Qur’an, on the other hand, declares there is “no compulsion in matters of religion”. The Da’esh slaughter and pilfer wherever they see fit. The Qur’an speaks of Allah as having “prescribed for Himself mercy”. The Da’esh kill innocent people yet the Qur’an not only forbids this but declares the slaying of any soul ‘haram’ (forbidden under Islamic Law) naming it ‘mubiqat’ (one of the abominable sins). Although I am sure the people at the Union know these differences their use of this picture unfortunately highlights the fact that many link Islam all too easily with extremism.
The choice of photo seems sadly inappropriate when we consider the huge casualties the Da’esh have inflicted on the Muslim populations of the countries in which they are gaining territory, Syria and Iraq. Spokesman for the Da’esh, Abu Muhammad al-Adnani, called on fighters to escalate attacks on not only Christians but also Shiite Muslims during Ramadan this year and was recorded as saying that the holy period should become “a time of calamity for the infidels… Shiites and apostate Muslims”. It is hard, nigh on impossible, to see why the Da’esh should ever speak for the Islamic religion if it openly wages war on the majority of the Muslim population.
The distinction between the Da’esh and the Islamic religion is so clear that many have rejected the more common name of ‘Islamic State’ because it endorses the Da’esh’s own claim firstly to be Islamic and secondly to be a state not limited by borders. In July of this year 120 MPs called on the BBC to stop referring to the militants by this name and the journalist Arsalan Iftikhar went so far as to suggest calling them the ‘un-Islamic State’. Even their name sparks controversy as Muslims seek to completely disassociate themselves from the extremist group. This is not an issue which, as the Durham Union Society have learnt, can be given little thought. By attributing these extremists by name, let alone by image, to the religion of Islam one offends thousands of Muslims who are striving to throw off the conscious or unconscious bias of others.
This is not to say that when talking about the Da’esh is it wrong to talk also of Islam. No-one can change the fact that they will continue to claim to be interpreting Islamic scripture correctly and will continue justifying their actions through the example of the Prophet Muhammad. However, just because these terrorists make this link does not mean we should. It is our role to re-educate those who fail to see the difference between terrorism and Islam.
I’m sure the Durham Union Society would agree with the above views. Promoting debate is often one of the best ways of educating people about an issue, but in doing so, it is inappropriate to teach a view of Islam which is, frankly, just plain wrong. It is also unsuitable to bias people towards one side of an argument before the discussion even begins.
There is a valid conversation to be had over whether extreme religiosity or theocracies can be compatible with Western Liberal Democracy. Unfortunately, singling out Islam for this debate is on the verge of unintentionally encouraging the rife bias in our society to represent the Islamic religion only through its extremist ties. This is not to say that there isn’t also an argument to be had about whether religion is ever truly moderate. Proclaiming a message of salvation, for example, will always involve some radical renouncement of the ways of the world. However, when approaching a topic which is already misunderstood by hundreds, it is completely unacceptable to promote further bias, however unintentionally. It probably is safe to say that they will never be making the same mistake again.
Image: Peter Bonnett via Flickr
