The Danish Girl: Review
by Florianne Humphrey
With Caitlin Jenner storming media headlines, Laverne Cox donning an orange jumpsuit in one of Netflix’s most famous series, and Andreja Pejic modelling for Vogue, the transgender community is starting to gain public awareness. It therefore seems appropriate that the most recent critically-acclaimed film is Tom Hooper’s The Danish Girl, a semi-autobiographical story of transgender Lili Elbe, born Einar Wegener, a Danish artist who was the first recipient of gender reassignment surgery.
Lili’s story is inspirational. Even in the 21st century, being a member of the LGBT+ community can be at best difficult and, in some communities, dangerous. But Lili Elbe not only embraced her true identity but also openly came out in the 1920s where, only a decade later, Hitler would send homosexuals and transsexuals to concentration camps. In the film, Lili has to fight both with the outside world and her inner self. Whilst she hides indoors for fear of persecution, a conflict of identity persecutes her mind as she feels trapped in her masculine skin. Perhaps Lili’s suffering is truly expressed in her confession that she has considered suicide as a last, desperate attempt to destroy the body that she was not meant to live in.
As the title suggests, The Danish Girl’s leading role is ambiguous. It is not only Lili who is affected by the transitioning but also Gerda, Einar’s wife. This film gives voice to the other woman in the relationship who not only had to support her husband through his terrible ordeal but also lost him in the process. What do you do when the man you fell in love with becomes a stranger? However, it is more than just a distancing. For Gerda, Lili’s transitioning is a form of bereavement. This is a side of transgender politics that is less discussed. The Danish Girl’s success comes from its neutrality as it hails the bravery of both Lili’s decision to transition and Gerda’s relentless loyalty, whilst their weaknesses – Lili’s affair with a man and Gerda’s increasing closeness with Lili’s old friend, Hans – are also honestly portrayed. But it is ultimately Lili’s question to Gerda “why did you decide to help me if you knew everything would be different?” that shows what love truly is.
From Stephen Hawking to a transgender artist, Eddie Redmayne has proven that he can undertake difficult roles with both success and sensitivity. This has sparked debates about whether a transgender actor should have played Lili, however, just as a transgender actor should be free to play a cis-gendered character – though discrimination remains – so should Redmayne’s sexuality not bar him from acting roles. Everyone should play everything, as Redmayne himself asserted when questioned on the issue, and both his extraordinarily convincing acting and Bafta nomination cements his title as one of the best in the new generation of British actors.
The Bafta nominations for this film do not stop with Redmayne – Swedish actress Alicia Vikander is also up for Best Actress, one she deserves just as much as her co-star. Whilst Redmayne’s character is a pioneer for the transgender community, Vikander’s character represents female progression. For an era where ‘feminism’ was a relatively new concept, Gerda typifies all that is inspirational in a woman. She is a talented, determined artist who leaves her hometown to pursue her career; she personally seeks out medical help for Lili, confronting anyone who subverts their efforts; her humour and playfulness cut through the deeply tragic plot, and she also remains fiercely loyal to her husband, adapting her marital love to that of almost sisterly support. Vikander’s character, however, is also genuine. Gerda is not a superhero but a complex human being and therefore, naturally, she copes through both laughter and tears.
Now that Christmas is over, summative deadlines are looming, and Durham will be even colder and wetter than usual, a film that beautifully retells a pivotal event both in an individual’s life and world history should be your first thing to see this term.
