The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

On her deathbed in 2005, an elderly woman asks her daughter to read her the diary of Benjamin Button (Pitt), born in 1918 into the body of an old man and destined to age in reverse. As his mind grows older but his body appears younger, Benjamin falls in love with Daisy (Cate Blanchett), but their quest for romance, more than any other, is a race against the unstoppable passage of time.

David Fincher has come a long way since directing music videos for George Michael. Following a quick glance at the synopsis of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s original 1921 short story there are many filmmakers that might spring to mind ahead of the director of Alien3, Se7en and Fight Club. Indeed, this may well be the first Fincher film not to feature a single serial killer, psychopath or conspiracy theory.

If one considers, however, what a complete maudlin hash some directors could have made of the source material, it becomes apparent that Fincher is the perfect man for the job; it is the sense of understatement and self-awareness that he brings to this tragicomic fairytale of epic love which keeps Benjamin Button securely on the emotional rails from start to finish.

Before his justly-acclaimed performances in Babel and The Assassination of Jesse James, it was Fincher who brought out the best in Brad Pitt in ’90s greats Se7en and Fight Club, and their latest collaboration has given Pitt his finest role to date.

Now 45, Pitt has finally managed to shake off the pretty-boy image of old, and as Benjamin he is able to combine his good looks and his considerable talents as an actor, all too often overlooked in the past. From the wizened teenager to the poster-boy octogenarian, Pitt never misses a beat, displaying impeccable comic timing (seeing an old man go through puberty, with the growing appeal of women and alcohol, is something that will stay with you) and heartbreaking pathos in equal measure.

He is given excellent support from the rest of the cast. Cate Blanchett is (perhaps predictably) faultless playing the same character over the course of 60-odd years, especially in the latter stages of the film, when she has to deal with Benjamin’s increasingly youthful looks in the face of her own natural ageing. Jason Flemyng (as Benjamin’s biological father), Taraji P. Henson (as the African-American nurse who raises him) and Tilda Swinton (as his surprising first love) also put in fine performances.

Unusually for such an Oscar-friendly film, the special effects also deserve a mention; Brad Pitt’s gradual progression from a shrivelled, decrepit foetus to a fresh-faced twenty-something seems so immaculately natural that it’s easy to take for granted. The fact that Benjamin Button couldn’t have been made ten or even five years ago is surely one in the eye for those who see special effects as the nemesis of ‘serious’ or ‘highbrow’ cinema.

Critics have compared Benjamin Button to Forrest Gump, and the reasons are clear enough: both have lengthy running times, both cover great swathes of American history, and both are adapted screenplays are the work of Eric Roth.

However, while Tom Hanks meets the likes of Elvis, JFK and Nixon on his journey through the 20th century, Benjamin’s story is resolutely personal throughout. The film certainly doesn’t ignore the major events of the era (Benjamin is born on the night WWI ends, and serves in the Navy in WWII), and the inexorable march of time is an ever-present theme, but Fincher refuses to overindulge in cheap nods to the fashions and pop songs of each successive decade.

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button clocks in at almost three hours, but you won’t notice. Amid the usual January-February barrage of high-quality Oscar contenders, it stands out as one of the funniest, most moving and most beautifully-made films of the year.