Il y a longtemps que je t'aime

When French writer Philippe Claudel directed for the first time last year he created one of France’s most emotive films to date. The winner of this year’s BAFTA for Best Foreign Film, I’ve loved you so long is a drama which focuses on the rehabilitation of a woman damaged by her past.

The film sees Juliette (Kristin Scott Thomas) arrive in the city of Nancy reuniting with younger sister Léa (Elsa Zylberstein) after a mysterious absence of fifteen years.

Juliette moves into her sister’s house, living alongside her sister’s family: Luc (Léa’s husband), their two adopted children and her father-in-law. The busy household does little to engage Juliette, who leads a withdrawn existence and spends most of her time in limbo, chain-smoking. The film recounts Juliette’s slow re-entry into society and family life. Her tentative steps are aided by the few who support her, but are also discouraged by the numerous rejections she suffers in her job hunt.

Claudel builds up suspense by letting each scene fade into darkness, and by introducing music which at times oddly suggests more of a horror movie than a drama. The tension is heightened by withholding the reasons behind Juliette’s behaviour. The audience is given hints in scenes at the job centre and family dinners, but is excluded from moments where the truth is discussed fully until the end of the film. The downside of this is that the audience perhaps has to wait too long for a revelation that cannot live up to expectations.

Without knowing the reasons behind her behaviour the audience is left with an ambiguous portrait of Juliette. Is she a formidable character who has committed a horrendous act, or a character that has understandable reasons for her actions?

We are left in an interesting predicament where we must decide for ourselves what to make of Juliette. As brother-in-law Luc makes known, Juliette could be a threat to his family and her demeanour does appear to rebuff those close to her. Those similarly quick to judge will find it hard to sympathise with Juliette’s enigmatic behaviour for close to two hours and Juliette does little to prevent this accusation. However, others may be less critical.

English-born actress Scott Thomas is well deserving of the nominations she has stacked up for her skill in playing such a complex role. This is her best performance to date, far beating that seen in The English Patient. Scott Thomas brings a necessary subtlety to the emotions of Juliette without turning the film into a melodrama. She forms a believable fragile bond with her on-screen sister.

The film deals with complex family relationships and questions the limits tolerated in family love. Luc’s mute father (Jean-Claude Arnaud) provides a particularly interesting point of contrast to the other characters in this respect. Despite living with a barrier that separates him from the world, it is his character that is perhaps most engaged with the feelings of others, and he is the figure of warmth and stability of the household.

This is an emotive film which will stay with you long after the closing credits. It suggests good things to come from Claudel. With the success last year of other films such as Bienvenue chez les ch’tis, and Paris it is clear French directors continue to be a force to be reckoned with. With powerful pieces such as I’ve loved you so long, we can only hope films continue to make it across the Channel so audiences here have the opportunity to appreciate them.