The Crucible review: ‘claustraphobic’
By Beatrice Scudeler
If asked to describe Arthur’s Miller’s The Crucible in one word, I would undoubtedly choose ‘claustrophobic’. A play that encompasses the entirety of human experience, with its virtues and sins, truths and falsities, demands an intimate setting to reflect the suffocating atmosphere of Salem. I therefore cannot imagine a more appropriate venue for Castle Theatre Company’s production than Castle’s Norman Chapel – the imposing columns, brought to life by a single, penetrating light, cast eerie shadows on the walls and ceiling.
The arrangement of the benches around the focal area of the room left a narrow space for the actors, and placed them right in the middle of the audience, destroying any division between stage and spectators, between pretence and real life. Just as Abigail and her companions were so convincing in their delirious talk of the devil as to destroy a whole town with their lies, so I was brought into this world of insanity and superstition, and utterly felt part of it for the evening.
Even before the play began, we could see a man kneeling by a young girl, who revealed himself to be Reverend Parris. Hamish Lloyd Barnes did a tremendous job in this challenging role, which in the wrong hands could make the character appear distant and imperturbable. Instead Barnes portrayed the Reverend as delirious and vulnerable, inspiring infinite pity, and yet far from devoid of strength.
Equally impressive was the rendition of Abigail Williams, Parris’s niece, given by Eleanor Hartland. Frighteningly determined, and bordering on the psychotic, Hartland’s Abigail completely overpowered all those who attempted to stop her folly with piercing shrieks of sheer madness. One must admire her performance for its meticulous quality – Abigail was trembling from head to toe throughout the play, emphasising the hysterical state into which she was progressing.
Nevertheless, it was John Proctor and his wife Elizabeth – played by Freddie Parsons and Ellie Jones – who most conveyed the psychological intensity which The Crucible lends itself to so very brilliantly. From their first scene together they excelled at representing the dynamics of a married couple, with their love, recriminations, distrust, and ultimate reconciliation.
Parsons was a formidable Proctor; Act 4 was particularly brilliant, culminating with a blood-curdling scream and his realisation that ‘God is dead’. When the law of man overwhelms the mercy advocated by Christianity and dictated by one’s own moral compass, religion loses its meaning, and society – its very foundations. Jones provided a composed, restrained, yet absolutely fascinating counter to Abigail’s selfish folly. Her character was dignified and controlled in a way that none other was, reiterating the play’s motif of the quiet suffering of those who, despite being morally good, are forced into atoning for the mindless fears and wishes for revenge of the corrupted society of Salem.
Another such character was Rebecca Nurse, played by Emma-Louise Howell, whose selflessness and courage in facing her trial were truly moving. One cannot forget to mention Jake Hathaway’s ruthless Deputy-Governor Danforth, who perfectly depicted the great injustices that justice itself can cause, or Reverend Hale, performed by Theodore Holt-Bailey, who managed to encapsulate his character’s conflicted attitude towards the law and religion with absolute pathos. Finally, a remark must be made on Grace Bryan as Mary Warren – the overall feeling of the play as a generational conflict between the old and the young emerged brilliantly through her shift of loyalty between Abigail and Proctor.
Feeling increasingly as if I had been plunged into a dystopian society as the story unfolded itself, I could not help but ponder on the unique poignancy of Miller’s play, and its endless potential for examining the human heart. As I watched John Proctor bid farewell to his wife to go to his death, a broken man who has lost everything but has regained his integrity, I was left with an overwhelming impression that the moving force behind The Crucible is not the devil – even less people’s belief in him – but human nature itself.
Poster: Castle Theatre Company
