The case for continuity: Eric Williams’ ‘Capitalism and Slavery’

By Jack Neill

The writing of history is fluid; the discovery of new evidence results in acclaimed arguments being revised and challenged. Seldom are works so radical and ambitious that they remain relevant almost eighty years after their initial release. What is even rarer is for such an influential work to remain unpublished by a major UK publisher for seventy-eight years. Yet, this is exactly what has occurred this year; Eric Williams’ Capitalism and Slavery, in which Williams argues that slavery was abolished by Britain due to economic, rather than moral concerns, is to be published for the first time by Penguin, as a Modern Classic. 

Indeed, moral concerns over slavery arouse throughout the course of the eighteenth century, and Williams admires abolitionist’s fervour. Historians such as Roger Anstey have argued that the ideological crusade against slavery, headed by figures like William Wilberforce in Parliament and Thomas Clarkson, solely resulted in abolition. Yet, through a close interrogation of archival sources, Williams thawed the hagiography surrounding figures like Wilberforce, reminding us that although Wilberforce aided the abolition of the trade in 1807, he was less than eager to emancipate slaves, this did not occur until 1833.

Anti-slavery sentiment existed long before the 1807 Abolition Act. While it is difficult to date the first popular expression of abolitionist thought, Quakers in London expressed polemical attitudes towards the slave trade in 1761. If anti-slavery sentiments were such a decisive factor in abolition, why would the road to abolition be punctuated with such resistance and delay?

Some humanitarian protest was certainly economically harmful; 300,000 Britons participated in the sugar boycott of 1791. This certainly damaged slave traders’ profits – sugar was the main product cultivated by slaves in the Caribbean and Williams notes that “Strange that an article like sugar, so sweet and necessary to human existence… occasioned such crimes and bloodshed!” Surely if such action was so debilitating to the slave trade, Parliament would not have defeated the bill to abolish slavery in the same year. Williams contends that as slavery funded industrialisation the cotton mills of Lancashire began to generate profits larger than Caribbean plantations. Consequently, the declining slave trade was abolished as domestic factories began to produce larger profits; 20% of the nation’s exports and imports were to and from the Caribbean in the early eighteenth century, but this figure fell rapidly as the factory system established itself. 

This disturbing reality is why Williams is worth reading

Williams makes insightful points regarding race, affirming that racism was a direct product of slavery – the systematic degradation of an entire race was needed to uphold such an abhorrent system. This is certainly valid; the Tudor period was far from an age of equality. However, Miranda Kaufmann’s 2017 book Black Tudors reveals that people of African descent were far more common in England than initially realised. Tales of men such as Jacques Francis, who tried to recover weapons from the wreck of the Mary Rose in 1546 and would go on to be the first African to speak in an English court are fascinating. Such cases reveal the shift that took place once British colonies began to grow in the Caribbean. The onward march of capitalism transformed the nation’s economy, race began to be viewed through the prism of slavery. 

This racist degradation and its reduction of human lives to economic units is perhaps best highlighted by the 1783 ‘Zong case’. The captain of the slave ship Zong authorised the massacre of 133 slaves, who were hurled into the sea mid-voyage as food began to become scarce. If these slaves died before reaching land slavers would not be reimbursed for them by insurance companies, so they were mercilessly killed to save money. Despite public outrage over the case, it pre-dates the first Abolition Act by 24 years. This lack of humanity and the fact that this, upon countless other hateful violations of human life, did not immediately result in abolition is a reprehensible tinge upon British history.  

In 2015, 182 years after the final abolition of slave ownership in Britain’s empire, British taxpayers finally finished funding the repayment of a £20 million loan the government took out to compensate wealthy slave owners. We are closer to the horrific legacy of the slave trade than we realise, and many are quick to try and exonerate Britain due to humanitarian efforts and an abolishing slavery earlier than other nations. Yet, Williams removes this varnish of romantic exceptionalism from the narrative of abolition, faltering profits were more important to the state than the repulsive mistreatment of fellow humans. This disturbing reality points to why Williams is worth reading in 2022.

Image: Zulmaury Saavedra via Unsplash