Gig Review: ‘Joyous sadness’, Nick Cave and Warren Ellis at The Sage, Gateshead

By Jack Neill

Few of us can imagine suffering a loss as devastating as Nick Cave after he unexpectedly lost his son, Arthur, in 2015. Rather than retiring from music after such a traumatic loss, Cave channelled his overwhelming emotions of grief, suffering and acceptance on his outstanding, yet agonising, 2019 album, Ghosteen.

Cave’s resilience is profound – not even a global pandemic can terminate his artistic output; during the UK’s 2021 lockdown, Cave recorded Carnage with long term Bad Seed collaborator Warren Ellis over a period of three days. After two cancelled tours, Cave’s return to the stage was truly a special occasion, both poignant and uplifting.

Compared to a usual Bad Seeds affair, Cave performs with a stripped back band, consisting of Ellis on synthesiser, violin and backing vocals, Johnny Hostile on drums and, seldomly, bass and the wonderful backing singers Wendi Rose, T Jae Cole and Janet Ramus. While not a usual Nick Cave line-up, they are tight and sound equally raw and ethereal. There is an air of anxiety amongst the packed crowd at an event that, for many, will be their first restriction-free concert in eighteen months. However, any apprehensions the audience may have held fizzled away as Cave’s spider-like silhouette, as sharply dressed as ever, struts onto the stage to thunderous applause.

“Thank you all for risking your lives to come and see me”, Cave later quips. While in a post-vaccine world, the extent to which fans are risking their lives is questionable, it would not be unreasonable to assume many of the audience would do just that for Cave. Their devotion is almost religious, with fans in the front rows reaching out, hoping to hold their idol’s hand at various intervals. Cave’s connection with the audience is truly a sight to behold.

The set mainly consists of more recent songs from Ghosteen and Carnage. More casual Cave fans may be disappointed with the absence of Bad Seeds’ classics such as Stagger Lee and The Mercy Seat. However, several standouts make up for this: I Need You from 2016’s Skeleton Tree is a highlight – Cave sounds like a broken man; his voice cracks and tremors as he croons ‘I will miss you when you’re gone away forever’. There is hardly a dry eye in the venue. A cover of T.Rex’s Cosmic Dancer is met with great reception and Ellis’ violin solo adds a beautiful layer of texture to a fantastic cover.

The new songs from Carnage transfer exceptionally to a live setting. The blistering Hand of God is a more intense affair live and protest song, White Elephant, with an electronic bassline that later meanders into a gospel-like chorus that is akin to a hymn of religious benediction.

However, the highlight of these new tracks is the gorgeously visceral Shattered Ground. Cave’s voice warbles over Ellis’ beautifully ambient synth line about a failed relationship. Rich in metaphor, Cave intones “The moon is a girl with tears in her eyes, Who is throwing her bags in the back of the car, I am not even remotely surprised”. Many members of the audience realise that a mask is a very good substitute for a tissue. Despite this, tracks from Ghosteen are the highlight of the show. The fairy-tale-like Bright Horses paints a metaphorical picture of angelic imagery, describing horses with manes of fire that would not feel out of place in William Blake’s Songs of Innocence and Experience and contrasts them to the bitter reality of ageing and loss of joy that comes with grief; “And the little white shape dancing at the end of the hall Is just a wish that time can’t dissolve at all”.

Hollywood is a terribly intense track and a clear standout that transfers very well to a live setting. “This is a joyous song that sounds sad”, intoned Nick Cave before performing Night Raid on Friday evening. This is a perfect summary of Cave’s recent output; many are quick to dismiss his music discography as unnecessarily depressing, but, in the case of his recent music this could not be further from the case. Grief is a multifaceted process, and despite the initial gut-wrenching sorrow, there are tender moments. The memory of a lost loved one can be emotional but also joyous, and grief can be beautiful as it inspires us not to forget the bereaved.

Such a message is carried out in the final song of the set: after two encores, featuring murder ballad Henry Lee and the showstopping Into My Arms. Cave finishes with Ghosteen Speaks, a song that he describes to the audience as being “a prayer”. A meditation on loss, Cave enunciates “I am beside you, you are beside me”. This works on two levels; after the tragic losses many of us, including myself, have suffered over the past year, it is comforting to feel that a loved ones’ memory lives on beside us. However, it is also fitting, as Cave’s poignant words about bereavement on Ghosteen resonated terribly well with me and many others. The joy, and sadness, of his lyrics were like a hand to hold, and comfort in many sorrowful moments. Such an understanding of grief and the bond with the listener forges a truly unique concert. Such feeling is the true beauty of live music and Cave’s triumphant return to the stage is a concert to remember.

Illustration by Anna Kuptsova