The Booker Prize longlist: ‘The Mirror & The Light’ by Hilary Mantel
By Kate Pesenti
The wait is over. The Mirror & the Light, Hilary Mantel’s thrilling end to her trilogy painting the life of Thomas Cromwell is finally here. It has been hotly anticipated – not only did both of the two previous installments in the trilogy win the Booker Prize, but just a few years ago the U.K. seemed to take on a Wolf Hall fever, with the earlier books being adapted for Broadway, the West End and a hit TV show all at once. The stakes for the final instalment were clearly high. But never one to disappoint, Mantel has once again delivered an outstanding novel.
Picking up from where the second book left off, we see Cromwell in the immediate aftermath of Anne Boleyn’s execution. The French sword cuts her neck – a pause – and then the court’s plotting begins anew. We watch through Cromwell’s eyes and spectate as the son of a Putney blacksmith weaves his way through servants, nobles and numerous enemies in an endless strategy to protect his spot as Henry VIII’s right-hand man.
Anyone who has a vague understanding of Tudor history will know the major plot points of who lives and who dies. Whilst this naturally means there aren’t any crazy unexpected twists, it allows the reader to notice Mantel’s delicate foreshadowing. Anna Bolena and her accused lovers may be dead, but Cromwell knows his hands are stained with their innocent blood. Their haunting presence throughout serves us a reminder that Cromwell can’t escape those he has slighted or betrayed on the way to the top, either in this world or the world beyond.
Undoubtedly the most delightful part of The Mirror & the Light is Mantel’s nuance. Cromwell’s dealings are not always made explicit: often the meanings of certain actions only become clear pages later. Significant letters or a few whispered words will arrive but not be explained and this infuriating tension reminds us of how Cromwell is always one step ahead in the game. He might be our guide, but only up to a point: it is left to us to pay close attention to the clues. In many ways, Mantel invites the reader to be a courtier in their own right.
Mantel invites the reader to be a courtier in their own right.
Another real joy is the humour that can be found throughout the book, often through Mantel’s wickedly sharp characters. A scene early on shows Jane Seymour’s brothers confronting her in an attempt to find out whether the marriage night was successful. When she gives her answer, that Henry “wants me to do some very strange things. Things I never imagined a wife had to do”, the response is visually perfect comic timing: “Edward looks desperate. Tom begs, ‘Master Secretary?’”
I think perhaps that is what has made the trilogy so popular: the humanity of it. Henry VIII’s courtiers all reflect people we know in our own lives, from the sneaky social climbers to the bullies, the struggling lovers and waning friends. Mantel manages what the best historians always do: to make the characters of the past undoubtedly and beautifully real.
Mantel manages what the best historians always do: to make the characters of the past undoubtedly and beautifully real
The Mirror & the Light is a masterpiece of a book, as demonstrated by Cromwell’s story being once again up for the Booker Prize – and deservedly. The satisfaction of the series getting a hat-trick is so close, but seeing as it has never been done before, the odds are not necessarily in Mantel’s favour. Still, if she pulls it off, perhaps it won’t be so surprising. If her character is anything close to the real-life version, it wouldn’t be unlike Cromwell to manipulate something from the dead.
Image: Kate Pesenti
