The battle reshaping South Africa’s oceans
By Katie Meddins
Just a decade ago, the waters of Gansbaai, South Africa, were home to around one thousand great white sharks (Carcharodon carcharias). Now, fewer than ten individuals have been sighted in over twelve months. The shark populations of South Africa have taken a fatal blow, but why?
The mystery began in 2017 when the first carcass washed up – a small 2.6m long female. Over the next five days, three more great white sharks appeared on the shore, none of which had any evidence of net or hook marks. Human involvement had not been the direct killer of these sharks. As the pattern continued into 2021, a marine biologist from the Department of Ichthyology at Rhodes University, Towner, took matters into her own hands to solve the mystery.
She and her team took two key approaches. Firstly, they took necropsies of the most recently found sharks, and secondly, they undertook analysis of telemetry data. The necropsy results presented a key link between the majority of the shark deaths: they had all had their livers removed. In addition to this, all of the sharks had been torn open at the pectoral girdle (which lies just behind the gills), and several showed distinctive rake marks.
For Towner and her team, this immediately flagged a key suspect, later to be confirmed by helicopter observation in May 2022. The deaths had all been the work of two male orcas (Orcinus orca), named Port and Starboard, who had been frequenting the area since 2015.
The trophic system is being rearranged from the top downwards, as the top predators of Gansbaai have become prey
The deaths of so many great whites have been described as both “awe-inspiring and harrowing”, but the true extent of the damage brought to the ecosystem was not fully understood until Towner et al. published their telemetry findings in June of 2022. The data demonstrated that white sharks emigrated in direct response to these predation events, with departure eastwards being immediate and large-scale. Change-point analysis confirmed that this correlation was not a mere coincidence. Departures coincided exactly with orca presence and appearance of shark carcasses.
Devastating as this has been on the great white population, this is not the only species which has felt the impact. As those great whites who have managed to avoid Port and Starboard have fled, another shark species, the Broadnose Sevengills (Notorynchus cepedianus), has fallen into the orca’s firing line. In turn, the trophic system is being rearranged from the top downwards, as the top predators of Gansbaai have become prey. The risk of a complete trophic cascade is real, and havoc has already begun in this marine ecosystem. Notably, the local seals are no longer at risk of being hunted by the sharks and have shifted to their own predatory behaviour, even predating on the African penguins (Spheniscus demersus), a species which is already critically endangered. Rabies has long been an issue among seal populations along the South African coastline, but for the most part, predation by great white sharks has kept this outbreak manageable. With the sharks gone, this is no longer the case, and as of June 2024, it has been labelled as a rabies epidemic. The entire ecosystem will feel the effects of the loss of the ‘doctors of the ocean’.
It is evident that competitive displacement has occurred within the Gansbaai waters in recent years, but are Port and Starboard truly the ones who should hold the blame for the consequences? The answer is no.
While it is not unusual for orcas to consume sharks, they are not the main component of their diet under normal circumstances. However, the fish (such as salmon and bony fish) and squid that are usually their dietary staple are no longer as readily available to the orcas, with the oceans being overfished by 37% in 2024 alone. The result is that individuals like Port and Starboard are forced to find other sources of energy. Overfishing is already to blame for the deaths of 100 million sharks per year worldwide, and more than a third of total shark species are at risk of extinction, regardless of the changing behaviour of these two orcas.
Without change, the future for sharks and orcas is bleak both along the South African shores and worldwide. Following her investigation, Towner has been vocal about what needs to be done: “Strengthening international policies to combat overfishing, expanding marine protected areas and promoting sustainable fishing practices are key actions. That is, of course, if science is listened to.”
Image: Kaitlin Thoresen via Flickr

