A game of two halves: inflammatory football celebrations should be punished
By Dylan McLaren and Max Nicholls
In a feature included in every print edition, two writers take part in a head-to-head debate surrounding a key issue in the world of sport. This week, we asked Deputy Sport Editor Dylan Mclaren and Sport Contributor Max Nicholls whether they agreed or disagreed with the statement: Inflammatory football celebrations should be punished.
Yes (Dylan McLaren):
Following James Tarkowski’s 98th-minute equalizer against Liverpool earlier this month, Abdoulaye Doucouré chose to celebrate in front of the travelling fans by shushing them. This led to an irruption in the stands, and an on-field scuffle between the Frenchman and opposition midfielder Curtis Jones. Should celebrating a last-minute equaliser be allowed? Yes. Should Doucouré be punished? Also, yes.
The most provocative celebrations are the most iconic. Lionel Messi holding up his shirt at the Santiago Bernabéu in 2017 after scoring a last-minute winner was not well received amongst Real Madrid fans but is regarded worldwide as one of the greatest celebrations of all time. Such moments encapsulate the passion of players and fans and banning them outright would strip football of its emotion.
However, there is a line between passion and incitement. Messi and Doucouré were right to celebrate —there is nothing as beautiful in football as a last-minute goal against your rivals. However, the consequences of their celebrations make their punishment necessary, as negative things have happened as a result of their actions. Purposely provoking a large group of very recently distraught, often intoxicated people should at least result in a fine.
Governing bodies like UEFA, FIFA, and domestic leagues must act to prevent violence, and punishing inflammatory celebrations is a step toward achieving that
Inflammatory celebrations can lead to crowd trouble, violence, and put both fans and players at risk. Emmanuel Adebayor’s infamous celebration against Arsenal, where he sprinted the length of the pitch to taunt his former club’s fans, resulted in him being pelted with objects and could have led to serious injury.
Governing bodies like UEFA, FIFA, and domestic leagues must act to prevent violence, and punishing inflammatory celebrations is a step toward achieving that. The less incited the crowd is, the lower the risk of violence. However, banning celebrations outright would be unrealistic. During the COVID-19 pandemic, attempts to restrict celebrations by enforcing social distancing proved unfeasible. The passion of the game is simply too much.
Players will always celebrate, and they should. But if they do so in a way that deliberately provokes and escalates tensions, they must be prepared to face the consequences.
No (Max Nicholls):
In the dying embers of almost 100 minutes of football between two bitter rivals, in the last of 120 Merseyside derbies at Goodison Park, emotions ran high as it appeared Liverpool would have the last laugh. That was until James Tarkowski’s 98th-minute equaliser rocketed into the top corner unravelling scenes of unfettered chaos, both on and off the pitch alike. Poignantly, Abdoulaye Doucouré opted to celebrate in front of the distraught cohort of Liverpool fans rather than with his own elated fans. Irrefutably provocative and reminiscent of antics of Mario Balotelli or Emmanuel Adebayor, I cannot think of a more apt noun to encapsulate the events that unfolded at Anfield earlier this month than catharsis.
Catharsis: ‘the process of releasing and thereby providing relief from strong or repressed emotion’.
The term stems from the Greek ‘katharsis’ which literally means purification or cleansing. Its modern-day use is a predominantly theatrical one referring to when negative emotion is created amidst the audience, which is later overridden by a positive and unexpected change of fortune.
Doucouré’s state of elation whilst provocative and inflammatory is a by-product of ardent emotion– a fundamental feature of the game we know and love
To suggest Doucouré’s celebration came out of a place of malevolence would be a mistake, as such an action is essentially instinctual. Ever-growing frustration multiplied as it became apparent that Everton’s chances of winning and closing this chapter of Goodison Park history positively was increasingly fading as time ticked.
Therefore, the turnaround of fate– the anagnorisis in theatrical terms– prompts an unforeseen and uncontrollable release of emotion which is essentially unpreventable. It is not a reaction of violence, rather quite the opposite, one of elation and relief. Doucouré’s state of elation whilst provocative and inflammatory is a by-product of ardent emotion– a fundamental feature of the game we know and love. Conversely, an equal and opposite reaction occurs for Liverpool whose feelings of victory elation are suddenly repressed leading to the reactions of Curtis Jones and Arne Slot.
Inflammatory celebrations in a cathartic context should not be punished unlike malevolent or politically inflammatory ones such as Paul Gascoigne’s flute.
Image: Joel Solomon via Wikimedia Commons

