The ‘B word’: Why Sunak and Starmer hope Brexit is finished business

By Luke Alsford

Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer can agree on something, and they want you to agree with them too: Brexit is now over.

Sunak is so confident of this fact that his own minister, Steve Baker, supposedly disbanded the hard-line Tory Eurosceptic European Research Group’s WhatsApp group chat, as a declaration of Brexit’s completion. The cause for celebration? The passing of the Windsor Framework into law. The EU-UK agreement, purporting to solve the once thorny issue of Northern Ireland’s relationship with the EU that brought down Theresa May’s premiership and inflamed diplomatic relations with Brussels, sailed through the House of Commons with only 29 votes against.

It was not only the Conservative Party that threw themselves behind this deal, but the Labour Party too, for Starmer also appears to think Brexit is now done and dusted. The previously staunch Remainer himself pledged at the beginning of the year to “make Brexit work” if he were to be the next Prime Minister. The problem, however, for Sunak and Starmer is that as much as they both want British politics to move past Brexit, it is not an issue that has shown itself put to bed easily. Britain may have left the European Union, and just finished tying up some of the loose ends, but the Conservative and Labour leaders have every reason to worry that they will be confronting Brexit in the near and distant future.

Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer both want to fight the next general election with Brexit behind them. For the Prime Minister, he knows the last election was fought on Boris Johnson’s pledge to “Get Brexit Done”, a pledge that saw the Conservatives win 45 of formerly safe Labour seats in the North and Midlands that were once part of the ‘Red Wall’. Sunak already faces a definitive Labour polling lead in these seats and is now fighting off the Reform Party too. The successor to Nigel Farage’s Brexit Party, and now led by the founder and chairman of Leave Means Leave Richard Tice, it is appealing to voters who swung behind Johnson’s enthusiasm for Brexit, but who now believe that Brexit is yet to be done ‘properly’.

Sunak needs to convince voters in these heavily leave-supporting seats that Brexit has been achieved, to stand a chance in catching up with Labour and to stop the Reform Party from winning over voters who supported the Conservatives last time around.

Sunak is, therefore, trying to satisfy potential Reform Party voters by positioning himself as the strongman of the bread-and-butter Brexit issue of immigration. The Government’s hard-line anti-illegal immigration legislation and the unfounded claims that “billions” of people are “eager to come” to the UK are all testament to that fact immigration remains one of the most important issues for Red Wall voters, and an issue that polling suggests Labour is marginally more trusted to handle.

Sunak is particularly motivated to argue his case in the short term in order to prevent a challenge to his leadership by Boris Johnson. Sunak’s predecessor might be dogged by a Partygate inquiry and memories of how his premiership collapsed last year, but polling has in the past suggested that he is preferred by Red Wall voters, while Boris continues to publicly tout his Brexit credentials. Hidden behind the 20 Conservative no votes to the Windsor Framework were Boris Johnson and many of his closest allies. Neutralising Brexit as a political issue also helps to neutralise any remaining threat that Johnson poses to Sunak’s position as Prime Minister before the next election.

Neutralising Brexit as a political issue also helps to neutralise any remaining threat that Johnson poses

If Sunak wants the voters to move on from Brexit, then Starmer wants them to forget about Brexit altogether, and it all comes down to the Red Wall once again.

At the last election, Starmer was the Shadow Brexit Secretary who supported a second referendum on EU membership. That his approval rating remains in the red in Red Wall seats, even during the depths of Johnson’s leadership crisis, is evidence that this political history hurts his credibility with Leave voters in those seats, despite since pledging not to seek closer relations with the European Union.

Starmer knows that if Brexit is off the table, then there is less jeopardy to the Labour Party’s current popularity in the seats they lost at the last general election. Starmer also knows that without Brexit, the Labour leader has a risk-free open goal to pin all the blame for Britain’s economic challenges on the Government. Starmer can avoid mentioning, for example, that the Head of the OBR recently argued that Brexit has left the UK with a 4% smaller GDP. Instead, however, he can exploit the absence of Brexit in the political discourse of the two major parties, by attributing the country’s economic difficulties to 13 years of Tory mismanagement of the economy.

The problem for the Prime Minister and his Labour counterpart is that, just as they both think that their political ambitions rely on keeping Brexit off the news agenda, their fellow party leaders might believe that their electoral ambitions rest on the very opposite.

It will not have gone unnoticed that the Liberal Democrats have started talking about Brexit again: their leader Sir Ed Davey used his spring conference speech to call for closer economic relations with the European Union. This is because instead of the Red Wall, the Lib Dems are trying to launch an attack on the Conservative’s southern ‘Blue Wall’, where Liberal Democrats overtook Labour at the last election. The problem facing the Lib Dems is that, although a Labour polling revival might help split the Conservative vote in individual constituencies, the party are struggling to match their overall popularity in the ‘Blue Wall’ that they enjoyed in 2019.

It is therefore little surprise that Liberal Democrats are trying to pivot back to the pro-European Union themes of their 2019 election campaign, by publicly connecting British economic stagnation with the ‘elephant in the room of British politics’. In these seats, Brexit might not be over for Sunak and he might have to confront a political headache: Sunak needs to prove that Brexit has been implemented to voters in the Red Wall, while also appeasing the remain-voters in the Blue Wall. T

his is perhaps why Sunak so confidently sold his negotiated Windsor Framework and Northern Ireland’s unique access to the EU single market: Sunak was both able to declare Brexit as complete while presenting his Conservative Party as prepared to increase alignment with the EU; reports have even signalled that Chancellor Hunt is prepared to seek closer economic relations with the EU. This tension for Sunak is why it may well be wrong to write off Brexit as a political issue in the long term. If the British economy continues to stagnate relative to European rivals, then a future British Prime Minister, be it Sunak, Starmer, or a fresh political face, will have to confront the question of economic alignment with the European Union.

A future British Prime Minister… will have to confront the question of economic alignment with the European Union

The Liberal Democrats might pose problems for Sunak and Starmer, but it is the other yellow-themed party, the Scottish National Party, who will make Brexit an issue that is impossible to get away from within this decade and the next. For the time being, British politics is enjoying a standstill: as much as the new SNP leader Humza Yousaf will continue to demand a second independence referendum, and as long as the Scottish electorate remains relatively divided on the issue, then the Government will continue to deny that vote.

But if the clamour for Scottish Independence grows to a level that becomes unsustainable, such as to the threshold of 60% support, then a future Prime Minister will have to reckon with Scotland’s continued overwhelming support for EU membership. The SNP are deliberately playing on Brexit to try to improve support for independence: it is their leader in the Commons, Stephen Flynn, who consistently attacks the two main parties over Brexit at Prime Minister’s Questions. Britain’s current distant relationship with European institutions, and the current vow of silence on Brexit from both major party leaders, may well be the price to pay to save Scotland’s place in the Union.

The bottom line is that both Sunak and Starmer want to fight the next general election on issues other than Brexit. They may be enemies at the ballot box, but they are in an unconventional alliance on this fact. Labour is now talking about crime and the NHS, while the Conservatives believe they can win the next election on immigration, economic recovery, and the culture wars.

Brexit ensured that voters in the Red Wall seats defined the last election, and those voters remain crucial for the outcome of the next one. It is because Brexit was so decisive that both Labour and the Conservative Party want to stay away from it and focus their campaigns on policies and subjects that they believe they have the advantage over. Their problem is that the SNP, Liberal Democrats and the now Reform Party have all benefitted from stoking the division of Brexit.

As these parties seek to shore up support before the next election, they might well hope to benefit once again by keeping Brexit on the news agenda. Just as Francis Fukuyama rather prematurely declared the ‘End of History’ following the conclusion of the Cold War, the British public has every reason to be sceptical that Brexit is truly finished business. In fact, the fight over how to navigate the divisions that Brexit has caused has only just begun.

Image credit: Number 10 via Flickr