Tesla’s tipping point: when politics trump performance

By Joshua Vickers

Once a symbol of technological ambition, Tesla is now a cautionary tale of how hubris, politics, and erratic leadership can short-circuit even the most electrifying brands. 

Markets Take a Hit:

Tesla was once a stock-market marvel, built as much on faith as on financials. That faith has run dry. As of March 18th, its share price has slumped to $224.95, down 5.5% from the previous day and over 40% from its peak in 2024. For a company that once enjoyed near-religious devotion from retail investors, Tesla is now a textbook example of volatility. 

Analysts have modified their expectations accordingly. RBC Capital Markets has cut its price target from $440 to $320, citing persistent failures in the deployment of Tesla’s Full Self-Driving (FSD) software—once hailed by Elon Musk as Tesla’s golden ticket. Oppenheimer has decreased its vehicle delivery projections by 30,000 units, leading to a revised revenue forecast of $97.9 billion for 2025, reflecting a 2% drop from earlier estimates. Other analysts foresee more troubling prospects for the company, with Japan’s Mizuho group cutting its sales forecasts by 300,000.

Tesla’s stock price soared from $250 in March 2024 to nearly $490 by December before plummeting to $225 by April 2025.

Graph created by Joshua Vickers 

Meanwhile, competitors are forging ahead. China’s BYD has unveiled an ultra-fast charging system that refuels a car in five minutes, exposing Tesla’s once-vaunted Supercharger network as archaic by comparison. Investors, once firm in their belief in Tesla’s technological edge, are now asking an unexpected question: is the company still an industry leader? 

The Musk Problem:

If share-price woes were not enough, Tesla’s founder has added political controversy to the mix. A video clip from 20 January 2025, widely circulated online, appears to show Musk making a gesture during President Trump’s inauguration that many interpreted as a Nazi salute. International outrage ensued, particularly in Germany — one of Tesla’s key markets — where officials promptly condemned the act. Investors reacted similarly, reducing their exposure to Tesla stock. 

Musk, in a characteristically measured fashion, responded by dismissing the outrage and mocking critics online, ensuring the controversy remained front and centre

Musk, in a characteristically measured fashion, responded by dismissing the outrage and mocking critics online, ensuring the controversy remained front and centre. His political entanglements are no longer the subject of speculation. In February, he appeared via video link at a campaign rally for Germany’s far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party, urging supporters to “fight, fight, fight” for their country’s future. The endorsement prompted a sharp rebuke from Chancellor Olaf Scholz, who warned against corporate meddling in extremist politics. 

Consumers have also begun to react. In Spain, disillusioned Tesla owners are slapping protest stickers on their vehicles, lamenting their purchases in light of Musk’s ideological shift. In Britain, activists have gone further, using a Tesla to carve “don’t buy a Tesla” into a beach as a public statement against Musk’s political antics. 

Trump and Musk: A Volatile Alliance:

Tesla’s troubles are compounded by an alliance of convenience with a president as unpredictable as its CEO. Trump has framed criticism of Tesla as “economic sabotage,” but his tariff war—initially expected to benefit Tesla by disadvantaging foreign automakers—has instead backfired, delaying Tesla’s European expansion and cutting into its once-thriving market share in China. What was supposed to be a protective measure for American manufacturers has morphed into yet another destabilising factor for a company already on shaky ground. 

A Reckoning for Tesla:

Tesla retains some competitive advantages. While its Supercharger network is no longer unrivalled, it remains the most expansive in North America. Its battery technology is still formidable. Yet its autonomous-driving ambitions face regulatory hurdles, with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) investigating multiple safety complaints. Consumer Reports continues to rank Tesla’s driver-assistance technology below its legacy rivals, warning that public trust will remain fragile until the system consistently outperforms human drivers. 

Meanwhile, America’s competitive landscape is shifting. Ford and GM are accelerating their EV programs, while startups such as Rivian and Lucid Motors are securing government contracts and poaching Tesla engineers. Musk’s grip on the EV throne is loosening, and competitors are eager to claim the crown. 

The Cost of Miscalculation: 

Tesla’s present predicament serves as a case study of the perils of politicised leadership. Once the poster child for the EV revolution, it now faces financial, reputational, and competitive threats. Whether its downward spiral is primarily a result of Musk’s political dalliances or broader industry trends is open for debate. What is undeniable is that in today’s hyper-scrutinised corporate landscape, the cost of miscalculation is substantial. 

Tesla’s present predicament serves as a case study of the perils of politicised leadership

If Tesla cannot untangle itself from its CEO’s theatrics and its strategic missteps, it may soon discover that the market for electric vehicles—much like Musk’s core audience—has moved on without it.

Image: The White House via Wikimedia Commons