Sudan brings case against UAE to the International Court of Justice

By James Mackinnon

Sudan has filed a case to take the United Arab Emirates (UAE) to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) over alleged “complicity in genocide”. Sudan has been involved in a civil war since April 2023, causing a humanitarian crisis of mammoth scale, with over 12 million people displaced and 60,000 dead in the Khartoum region alone. Yet the conflict has arguably not received enough coverage, shadowed by the focus on the Ukrainian and Palestinian crises, and hindered by the difficulty of reporting in the country.

The origins of the civil war go back to the coup of 2019, where the general of the Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF), Abdel Fattah al-Burhan, in conjunction with the leader of the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), Gen Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo (known as Hemedti) ousted the Sudanese dictator Omar al-Bashir, who had been ruling for 30 years. Following this coup, protestors managed to negotiate a military-civilian government, which was overthrown in another violent coup in October 2021. A council of generals was then set up, led by the two military men at the centre of this dispute, al-Burhan as President, and Hemedti as Deputy. Since then, both generals have jostled for power, disagreeing on proposed civilian rule and on the integration of the RSF into the Sudanese army, which erupted into full conflict in April 2023. 

In the Khartoum massacre, both al-Burhan and Hemdti oversaw the killing of over one hundred protestors to their military rule, dumping at least 40 of the bodies into the river Nile

Atrocities have occurred since the 2019 coup. In the Khartoum massacre, both al-Burhan and Hemedti oversaw the killing of over one hundred protestors to their military rule, dumping at least 40 of the bodies into the river Nile. The charges made are specifically in connection with ethnic-based attacks, rapes, and looting, committed by the RSF and allied Arab militias against the non-Arab Masalit tribe from April to November of 2023 in West Darfur. It was deemed a genocide by Human Rights Watch, and by the United States in January this year. 

In terms of the strength of the case, evidence for the UAE’s support for the RSF is clear. Both Saudi Arabia and the UAE immediately granted Sudan $3 billion in support after the 2019 coup, and, since then, the UAE has added another $6 billion worth of investments that include agricultural projects, a Red Sea port, and the building of a hospital in neighbouring country Chad, and a newer one in South Sudan. Broadly, Saudi Arabia has been seen to be backing al-Burhan and the SAF, calling for ceasefires and providing humanitarian aid. In contrast, the UAE has been seen to be backing Hemedti and the RSF, and thus many have seen the conflict as a sort of proxy war between Riyadh and Abu Dhabi. Further to this financial aid, UN experts monitoring the arms embargo on Darfur have previously described accusations of the UAE smuggling weapons to the RSF through airstrips in Chad as credible, and even through the hospital there the county funded under the guise of the red crescent, leading to fears of the same intentions for their new hospital in South Sudan. 

The potential outcome for the UAE in investing in such a war is no secret: gold. Sudan is rich in the material, and Russia is an example of a country which has already exploited this. The UAE collaborated with Russia in supporting the RSF through the paramilitary Wagner Group (now taken over by the Kremlin following Wagner’s death), active in Sudan since 2017 and when it protected mineral mines in areas where the RSF was active. Gold is shipped from these areas to the UAE en route to Russia, with the UAE receiving an estimated $16 billion of these exports annually. Despite having no gold mining operations, the UAE officially has 75 tonnes in gold reserves, according to the World Gold Council. Moreover, in 2023, the U.S. Treasury Department sanctioned two firms associated with Hemedti that operate in the gold industry, Al Junaid and Tradive: one based in Sudan, and the other in the UAE. Further to economic gain for the UAE in this effective proxy war against Saudi Arabia, any RSF gain would create leverage to weaken Riyadh’s influence and grip over the Middle East. 

The potential outcome for the UAE in investing in such a war is no secret: gold

Despite evidence for the UAE’s support of the RSF, concrete proof that the UAE ordered or were aware is lacking, and Sudan did not come to the court clean-handed. The genocide took place in their country, and consequently they themselves could even be seen to be “complicit in genocide.” Officially, in response to the case application, the UAE said that it was a “cynical publicity stunt aimed at diverting attention from the established complicity of the Sudanese Armed Forces in the widespread atrocities that continue to devastate Sudan and its people.” It maintains that it is committed to addressing the humanitarian crisis and has “consistently called for an immediate ceasefire” in Sudan. 

Either way, the outcome of the trial will not be legally binding, but will carry significant political weight. Al-Burhan likely sees an opportunity to improve his claim to power, seeking international legitimacy for his continuing fight against the “genocidal” and foreign-backed RSF. In addition, should the UAE be found guilty, international pressure may force them to reduce their aid to the RSF, improving al-Burhan’s odds at victory against an underfunded opposition. In the meanwhile, the continuing conflict and the increasing presence of weapons in the region is fuelling the rising possibility of violence and civil war in South Sudan, where another president and vice president are at the centre of the tensions.

Image: International Court of Justice via Wikimedia Commons