Teenagers seek human rights judicial review over tuition fees

by Julia Chapman


In the wake of the increase in tuition fees, lower sixth form students Katy Moore and Callum Hurley have taken up the battle against the change and are petitioning for a judicial review of the matter.

The pair believes that the newly altered tuition costs contradict European human rights on discrimination, as fewer students will be in a position to afford higher education.

The recent government decision to permit universities to charge tuition fees as high as ÂŁ9,000 has been met with a great deal of backlash from students. Moore and Hurley, however, are taking the protests a step further and are attempting to invalidate the decision.

Their justification for the action lies in the details of Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which stipulates that anyone is allowed certain rights and freedoms without discrimination, the right to education included.

At many universities throughout the UK, tuition fees are set to nearly treble from the current ÂŁ3,375 a year. Because this means that fewer students will be able to afford a university education, Moore and Hurley believe that the change is unjust, and even illegal.

The government will try to offset the decrease in opportunities for poorer students in planning to reward promising students from families with low incomes scholarships that could pay for up to two years of their university tuition. There will also be higher expectations of universities to make post-A level education worth the cost.

Many universities have already set their tuition fees for the academic year beginning in 2012, and Imperial College has just announced that they will be charging ÂŁ9,000 per year. Cambridge and Oxford Universities are leaning towards the maximum amount as well, although Durham has yet to make a decision on the matter.

Moore and Hurley, from London and Peterborough respectively, are being represented by Phil Shiner of Public Interest Lawyers. Their case is being funded by legal aid and will be taken up with the High Court in March.