Decision time for JCRs
The face of Durham’s colleges is changing as the decision of whether to become an independent charity or a Durham Student Organisation (DSO) is put to the vote this term.
So far, the DSO option has proved popular with Mary’s, Hild Bede, Van Mildert and Aidans all voting in favour. Van Mildert’s result was resounding with just 42 out of 412 voting against.
So far only Grey has decided to become an independent charity.
Mary’s President Emily Warburton-Brown commented on the college’s decision to become a DSO: “for us it’s the right move”. She explained that St. Mary’s JCR works closely with the College Principal and, having become a mixed college only six years ago, “there is much work still to do.” As a DSO “we can get a lot out of working with the University.”
But the President of Grey College, Adam Ruddock, believes that becoming an independent charity “allows the JCR to continue what it does best.”
The referendum has been forced upon colleges owing to a change in the law. At the moment, JCRs, SRCs and GCRs operate as exempt charities but the Charities Act of 2006 dictates that they cannot continue to do so.
Professor John Ashworth, Deputy Warden of Durham University, explained that colleges now have two options: “The first is to opt into the Durham Student Organisation (DSO) framework, which is a new model of governance which would see JCRs nested in the University.”
“The second model entails independent registration with the Charity Commission.”
He added: “As the JCRs are currently voting on this issue it would be inappropriate for the University to comment further.”
But both options have their pros and cons. As charities, colleges will retain full democratic independence from the University. DSOs will no longer be Student Unions in the eyes of the law but will still be allowed to operate independently.
St. John’s College JCR voted to become an independent charity in 2009. President Jonathan Berry explained his support for the decision: “The JCR […] exists to be, a Student Union for the college; it represents and fights for student issues within college.”
Mr Berry continued: “The notion of signing away the whole JCR to the College/University […] sends shudders down my spine.”
“The current strength and purpose of a JCR may get lost over time in university bureaucracy. I don’t want to come back in 50 years time and find that the JCR is nothing more than ‘student volunteers’ at college events.”
And Ustinov President, Matt Hann, questions the “strange” name of DSO. “Could this be the first step to removing Common Rooms’ representative function and making them simply organisations for delivering something called ‘the Student Experience’ as part of Experience Durham?”
But DSU President Sam Roseveare, who negotiated the DSO framework with the University, argued that it is only a “core framework, at a high level” and so should not affect colleges’ individual operations too much. “The University is trying to preserve the current system” and retain the high quality of student experience. “We’ve been trying to get the best deal for colleges” he added.
Mr Roseveare remains unbiased towards either option. He appreciates that the strength of Durham colleges lies in their diversity and “different options are good for different colleges”. “JCRs do a fantastic job.”
He explained that the £10,000 cost of becoming a charity (incurred by insurance and accountancy) is not as forbidding as it might seem. For Van Mildert, the college with the highest annual turnover of more than £250,000, the amount is nominal. And, as charities, colleges may find it easier to elicit donations.
Meanwhile, colleges that become DSOs will have to transfer their physical assets to the University, which some fear could be dangerous.
Bureaucracy and an increased workload for sabbatical officers have been highlighted as downsides of becoming a charity. But Ustinov President Mr Hann believes that “the reporting structure in the DSO model would involve more work more regularly, especially for treasurers” whilst only an annual report and a financial report would be necessary as a charity.
Most colleges are expected to make a decision by the end of term.
Cuth’s has not yet voted. JCR President, Paul Harwood, said: “I have tried to remain open minded throughout the process but I have to say that I lean towards maintaining the status quo and remaining an independent charity.”
And Ustinov College has decided to delay making a decision until there is “greater clarity about both options.” Mr Hann said: “there is a lack of clarity on the implications of the Independent Charity Option; on the other hand, I feel there are areas of vagueness, imprecision, and even contradiction within the DSO model.”

