Takeo takes on Tokyo

Francesca Howard
Music Editor

Earlier this week I spoke to Durham University Japanese student and viola player Takeo Broadhurst, currently on his year abroad at Waseda University, Tokyo. As the only international student in the 200-strong Waseda Symphony Orchestra, Takeo reflects on his fascinating musical experiences over the past two months and gives Indigo a rare insight into the workings of the prestigious orchestra. They have worked with international conductors including Simon Rattle and play at the Berlin Philharmoniker every year as part of their month-long, annual European tour.

How did you join the Waseda Symphony Orchestra?

“The orchestra isn’t particularly accessible for international students because all the information is sent out in a weekly email in complex Japanese. I’d always have to ask my viola manager for the essential information and without her help it would have been impossible to join. I’m the only international student in an orchestra of 200 people. When it came to the actual rehearsals, they’d use different symbols to indicate different things in the music, so I had to learn what it all meant.”

Despite the obvious language barriers, it must be pretty incredible to be part of a student orchestra with an international reputation… does it live up to this?

“We play in professional venues all over the city, which is really exciting. There’s also a lot of coverage of the orchestra online and on YouTube of our performances. The turnover of repertoire is really impressive, and we cover a lot more than DUOS (Durham University Orchestral Society) in a term, and I’m playing in concerts all the time. Unlike any orchestras in Durham, we have a professional conductor, which is incredible. We pay a lot for membership… 5,000 yen a month (approx. £45) but it’s worth it. The level of professionalism extends to rehearsals too – no one is ever on phones, eating, drinking, chatting… it’s full concentration for the three and a half hour rehearsals that we have three times a week.”

Did you have to audition as you do for DUOS and other Durham ensembles?

“There is no audition process at all, which is unheard of in the best university orchestras in the UK, but I guess it’s because they expect more commitment. Only the most committed will even think about joining. In Tokyo they don’t care about your experience. I’ve played for the longest by far out of everyone in the viola section but I’m not the best. Many students have only been playing their instruments for a few years or took it up at the beginning of university. They join the freshman orchestra in their first year and sit in on all of our rehearsals. This gets you up to the standard of the Waseda Symphony Orchestra very quickly. By comparison, DUOS members have been playing their instruments for over ten years and have lots of playing experience, but they can afford to be really lazy in rehearsals.”

Why do you think attitudes are so different in Japan to UK student orchestras?

“Well, with every piece we play, the seating is changed. Everyone is always moving around. I think this makes things more equal – no one person is the best player in a section. There is this unspoken belief that everyone is of equal value in their contribution to the orchestra. Every single person is part of a subsection of the executive committee, with section leaders, so it’s a collective effort from everyone. The section leaders are not necessarily the best players – it’s just a managerial role. After rehearsals, we have 20-minute meetings about how we can play better as a section.”

And why do you think that commitment is more important than the individual standard of the musicians or their playing experience? 

“Because there’s more of an awareness about how each other is playing. The players are constantly giving feedback to each other, playing as a section and matching each other. There is a big emphasis on your section, and as a result, everyone is more connected in the thinking. I get most frustrated when people aren’t aware that they’re playing with everyone else in the orchestra and they’re not listening to the people around them. In England, you can’t tell people that they’re wrong, whereas here everyone is franker about it.”

Would you therefore say that humility and respect are particularly valued or even expected of players in the Waseda symphony orchestra?

“Yeah. I already knew you had to adjust your language when you speak to different people in Japan, but I guess that’s the same in England – it’s just more extreme here. In the orchestra you show respect when you bow to the conductor at the beginning and end of every rehearsal as a thank you. It is a given that if you are younger in a student society, you have to be respectful of the older years by addressing them with their second name. I remember finding it especially shocking when a fourth-year girl came up to me and personally critiqued my playing in general after a rehearsal. I wasn’t used to it, but it’s not seen as negative here because you’re helping them.”

So, an awareness of others and self-improvement is really important? 

“Yeah. Everyone is at a similar technical standard by the time they’re the oldest in the orchestra and a lot are still having private lessons, so they are in a good place to give advice. Whereas in DUOS, everyone is quick to criticise other people’s playing but won’t take it themselves. This is not very constructive for rehearsals. In Tokyo, everyone puts in more effort and the result is better – they sound much better than DUOS. There is also a willingness to accept advice. The sound is obviously very different from DUOS, the main reason being that there is a greater sense of awareness and listening.”

 

Photo by Gregor PetrikoviÄŤ