Pop ballads and unfulfilled potential: Jorja Smith at the 02 Academy Newcastle

By Francesca Howard

Recently shortlisted for the Mercury Prize last month, alongside the likes of Sons of Kemet and Everything is Recorded, singer-songwriter Jorja Smith has attracted much critical attention for her honeyed vocals and masterful lyricism, showcased in her much-anticipated album Lost and Found. The Walsall-born 21-year old is playing around the UK this month following her debut album release before continuing her tour overseas. It was announced earlier this year that Smith would be the recipient of the 11th Brit Critics’ Choice Award, certainly well-deserved after an impressive year of releases, which included collaborations with Drake on two tracks of his album ‘More Life’, ‘Get it Together’ and ‘Jorja Interlude’, followed by a couple of guest appearances at his shows. In January, Smith released the single ‘Let Me Down’ featuring Stormzy, but some listeners may be more familiar with her feature on the Kendrick Lamar’s soundtrack album for Black Panther as co-writer and singer of ‘I am’. Jorja Smith has made some powerful friends in the industry but has since moved onto bigger things in her solo career; she’s certainly come a long way since releasing her debut single ‘Blue Lights’ on Soundcloud in 2016.

She plays it safe, while ultimately guaranteeing its success.

I was fortunate enough to catch her performance at the Newcastle 02 Academy. The sell-out gig attracted quite a young crowd of eager 19-year-olds, many of whom knew all the lyrics. This is unsurprising, the rest of her songs on Lost and Found do not live up to the dizzying success of ‘Blue Lights’, lacking the daring or experimental innovation of her other releases and collaborations. Her heavily R&B and pop-inspired album certainly appeals to the generation of ‘sing-along’ fans. She plays it safe, while ultimately guaranteeing its success.

Nevertheless, the gig was an enjoyable experience. Jorja Smith brings a sense of self-assurance and serenity to the stage, aptly accompanied by the incense sticks rested on drummer Femi Koleoso’s kit. Six large, retro lamps were placed behind the band with soft light beams, carefully curated for soft silhouettes and an ethereal backdrop for Smith’s graceful entrance. In contrast to the dark, brooding and highly-charged performance of her support act (South East London’s reggae artist Mina Rose), Smith opted for a more statuesque pose and let her vocals do the work. She displayed incredible control in her upper range during ‘Goodbyes’ – showing off her classically trained vocals with astonishing fluency and ease – supported by a pared-down guitar accompaniment of open and broken chords. The drones and synth swells in the background of ‘Wandering Romance’, and ‘On Your Own’, sounded really well in the 02 Academy, blended with the vocals in an interesting and exciting ways, and hinted at a world of new sounds and possibilities.

It came across as very pre-rehearsed and lacked the freedom, adaptive qualities and spontaneity of a live performance…

It goes without saying, her voice is incredibly mature and versatile, yet it is also the connective tissue which brings the album together. Smith grew up listening to reggae, Neo-soul and has previously listed Amy Winehouse and Mos Def as two of her musical heroes. Sometimes her soothing vocals are reminiscent of James Blake and Lauryn Hill, while at other points, take ‘Don’t Watch Me Cry’ for example, her vocals are notably more ‘Adele-esque’. It is one of a number of tracks which disappointingly sells itself as a pop ballad; later in the show the keys player walks back onstage and plays the intro to ‘Tomorrow’ under a single spotlight, while fans scream on in excitement. During the first half of the gig, Jorja Smith didn’t seem particularly invested in what she was singing. It came across as very pre-rehearsed and lacked the freedom, adaptive qualities and spontaneity of a live performance, instead attempting to imitate the airbrushed recorded tracks.

She carries a quiet confidence, keeping her cards close to her chest.

About halfway through their set during ‘Lifeboats (freestyle)’, the band (who up to this point were incredibly tight but seemed a little despondent) really came into their own, with the drummer and the guitarist taking short solos. They seemed to be enjoying the gig more and were interacting with and playing off each other. The long-standing drummer in Jorja Smith’s group, Femi, also plays for the London-based experimental jazz outfit, Ezra Collective. At the end of the song he broke into an energetic improvisation demonstrating his incredible technical virtuosity, something which I felt had been missed in the rest of the set and was well received by the audience. Benjamin Totten’s subtle guitar solos occasionally emerged through the texture in earlier songs, but here he took centre stage. Smith respectfully decided to sit down to the left of the stage during his solo, marking a change in the dynamic between band and singer. His solo began as a soulful reflection with strong jazz influences, but quickly erupted into some heavy metal shredding. These glimpses of the sheer talent of the band members, with their plethora of musical influences, felt like an opportunity missed – something which Jorja Smith could have drawn on in order to develop and explore her own style, rather than restricting herself to the ballad form, for example.

So, where next? Attending her gig at the Newcastle 02 Academy confirmed what I already knew – Jorja Smith is an incredibly talented singer and a real joy to listen to. But to put it plainly, Smith has found herself stuck in a rut, performing the same songs every night with very little artistic freedom. Of course, that’s one of the realities of world tours, fame and doing what’s necessary to make a comfortable living as a musician. She’s playing it safe, but she also carries a quiet confidence, keeping her cards close to her chest. Perhaps her most ambitious work is yet to come.

Images by Justin Higuchi via Flickr Creative