Taiwan: province of China?

By Sofija Bednova

Taiwan’s complicated relationship with the People’s Republic of China can be traced back to the very founding of the Republic in 1949. As mainland China succumbed to Communist rule, Taiwan became a safe haven for the opposing Kuomintang faction, whose government soon took full control of the island. This history allows supporters of Taiwan’s independence to claim that, since the region was never under modern Chinese rule, calling it a ‘province of China’ is factually incorrect and should be avoided in official records.

President Xi Jinping, however, seems to have announced his approach to ending the controversy around this name, which has long remained a stumbling block of diplomacy. In a speech on October 9th at Beijing’s Great Hall of the People, the Chinese leader announced that “peaceful reunification” of Taiwan with mainland China will “definitely be realised”, prompting an immediate response from Taiwan’s authorities. The latter vowed to defend the island against Chinese aggression, although there are few doubts about who will prevail in case of a direct confrontation.

While China’s thinly veiled threats to annex Taiwan had been a regular occurrence, this time the Chinese government’s intentions could be more serious. As China asserts itself as a global superpower, it seeks to dominate the Western Pacific – a region where its influence is rivalled by the US alone. China seemingly thinks that taking over Taiwan will not only fix historical injustice, but also challenge American standing in the area.

In the event of an attempted takeover, China will inevitably face retaliation, primarily from the US and its allies in the Western Pacific

Although there are no official diplomatic relations between the US and Taiwan, the island represents a key strategic point for American authority abroad. China’s military base in Taiwan has potential to hugely undermine American capabilities to defend its partners in the Pacific, namely the Philippines, South Korea, and Japan. What’s more, it could threaten the US itself. If China gains control over the Bashi Channel, situated to the South of Taiwan, it will have unconstrained access to the Pacific, leaving the US strategically vulnerable to attack.

In the event of an attempted takeover, China will inevitably face retaliation, primarily from the US and its allies in the Western Pacific. The question is what form this counter-attack would take. The current treaty between the US and Taiwan, the Taiwan Relations Act, doesn’t contain any guarantees of military intervention in case of an attack from China. Neither does it relinquish such possibilities, however.

Even in the case of China’s assault on Taiwan, direct military action from the US seems unlikely. Considering the recent failure of America’s war in Afghanistan, it seems fair to assume that any proposal of open military confrontation with China will have to contend with a lack of public support in the US. Should China invade Taiwan, the US may be more likely to respond with increased supplies of ammunition and financial backing of Taiwan’s army.

The annexation of Taiwan would lead to many imperialist accusations from Western powers

Although the US’s allies in the northern hemisphere will be wary of a direct conflict, they would likely support financial retribution against China. Given that China is too powerful of an economic agent to be cut out from the world market, some form of a trade war or personal sanctions levied against key proponents of the regime will likely cause significant damage to the ruling elite. It will also help Western Allies to acquire enough bargaining power to negotiate fairer treatment of Taiwan.

If China were to succeed in annexing the island, it might initially suffer a momentary drawback in its financial standing. The exact level of detriment would depend wholly upon the depth of integration that China chooses to pursue. Nonetheless, incorporation of a predominantly hostile region into a country, even one as developed as Taiwan, is incredibly costly.

China’s political image would also suffer a heavy blow. The annexation of Taiwan would lead to many imperialist accusations from Western powers. In the worst-case scenario, China risks potential diplomatic isolation. One way for China to aid the situation and mitigate the effects of a forced unification with Taiwan would be to offer a ‘one country, two systems’ approach, letting Taiwan keep its economic system and some political freedoms, without national sovereignty.

This would surely be unlikely to convince many Taiwanese after China’s mistreatment of Hong Kong in 2019, but would perhaps provide a reasonable excuse for the international community to accept the de-facto annexation of the island.

Whatever Xi Jinping might have meant by “peaceful reunification” with Taiwan, given multiple conflicting interests at stake, it seems clear that unification would be anything but peaceful.

Image: daymin via Flickr