Super Bowl LIX: a review
By Max Nicholls
Two years after falling short in Arizona, the Philadelphia Eagles got their revenge over back-to-back defending Champions Kansas City Chiefs, and did so in an impressively emphatic fashion. Prima facie, the 40-22 finishing scoreline does not seem all that emphatic, just over a two-score victory. However, this scoreline flatters the Chiefs to say the least. From very early on, the Eagles’ dominance on both sides of the ball was apparent. 16 of the Chiefs’ 22 points came late in the fourth quarter, which coincided with Eagles backup quarterback Kenny Pickett coming into the game. The game wasn’t over mathematically, but the Eagles were coasting, and coasting comfortably. Unlike two years earlier and contrary to pre-game consensus, this game was not a close encounter- the Chiefs failed to venture into the Eagles’ half with the ball until the dying minutes of the third quarter. Think of this in rugby, football, or hockey terms and it quickly becomes apparent how uncontested the vast majority of this game was.
One of the most notable points of difference this time round was the disparity between the Chiefs’ offensive line and the Eagles’ defensive line. In the aforementioned Super Bowl matchup, Patrick Mahomes was not sacked a single time. A fact which the Chiefs offensive line were particularly keen to remind their opponents of after their victory in 2023 which manifested itself as a strong motivation for the Eagles this time.
From very early on, the Eagles’ dominance on both sides of the ball was apparent.
Such motivation was more than enough as the tables truly were turned in favour of the Eagles. The defence, coordinated and spearheaded by Vic Fangio, did not ‘blitz’ a single time. A blitz refers to when there is an increase in players pressuring the quarterback, more than just the defensive line. In the absence of a blitz, defences will only apply pressure with three or four defensive lineman up against at least five offensive lineman. Therefore, in spite of numerical sub superiority, the defensive front of Philadelphia were able to create havoc in the backfield and bypass their blockers with relative ease to record six sacks and sixteen pressures. Moreover and equally impressive was the Eagles’ ability to neutralise the Chiefs’ rushing attack, with negative rushing yards in the first half and less than 50 yards in total.
Patrick Mahomes opened this Super Bowl rattled, uneasy and underwhelming; an antithesis of the calm and composed figure responsible for guiding the Chiefs to five Super Bowl appearances in his relatively youthful career. Coming into the game in New Orleans, Mahomes had the lowest interception per passing attempt rate in Playoff NFL history, at a mere 1.1%. Superficially, Mahomes’ statline looks pretty impressive, recording more passing yards than Super Bowl MVP Jalen Hurts and scoring three touchdowns in the process. However, the vast majority of these yards and two of the three touchdowns came in an essentially redundant fourth quarter. In the first half, which proved crucial to the outcome, Mahomes recorded a mere 33 yards, no touchdowns and two interceptions with a dismal passer rating of 10.4. It was objectively the worst half of his career, punctuated by a 38-yard pick six for rookie Cooper DeJean, on his birthday.
…the defensive front of Philadelphia were able to create havoc
The other Eagle celebrating his birthday on the day of his first Super Bowl appearance was Saquon Barkley- the league’s offensive player of the year. Having achieved over 2,000 yards rushing over the season, which was just shy of the all-time record, it was paramount for Steve Spagnuolo’s defensive unit to nullify his threat of breaking free to the extent he did against the Washington Commanders in the NFC Championship. Unlike many-a-defence this year, this was something the Chiefs achieved, limiting the first-year Eagle to a mere 2.3 yards per carry compared to a season-long average of 5.8. The Chiefs achieved this by committing additional personnel to the interior, which proved highly effective in containing Barkley and halting his runs before he could reach the second level and exploit the space that this affords. However, this came at a significant cost to the Chiefs, as it allowed Jalen Hurts and the Eagles’ passing game to flourish.
Jalen Hurts, gifted strong territory by his defence on a number of occasions, was able to capitalise unrelentingly. Statistically, his performance was the most efficient in Super Bowl history with 0.51 expected points added per dropback. Caveated by one loose interception, Hurts was essentially flawless in both domains; rushing and passing. Ultimately, he proved to be the deserving recipient of the MVP award contributing almost 300 yards, throwing two touchdowns and ‘rushing’ for one more. Perhaps the most glowing compliment to Hurts’ performance is the fact he was substituted out with the coaching staff assured of victory with plenty of time still on the clock.
Image: All-Pro Reels via Wikimedia Commons

