SU delays revealing results of controversial election

By Jack Parker

Voting has ended in the Students’ Union Officer and Trustee elections – but the results may not be known for some time.

The SU was due to publicly reveal the results of the seven election races at Dunelm House on Thursday 27th February, but cancelled the announcement the day before by stating: “We’re anticipating there may be ongoing election investigations that will need to be resolved before the result of the election can be declared. The results will be declared on our website as soon as possible.”

The result declaration will take place once any outstanding formal complaints from voters have been resolved. It has not been announced how many complaints have been raised in total.

An independent investigation into the election, overseen by the Durham University Secretary, had also been announced earlier the same week by Deputy Returning Officer Gareth Hughes.

In an update posted on their website, the Students’ Union said: “We are required by our election regulations to resolve all complaints in full before declaring the results in any election.

“Any of our members have a right to submit a complaint during any election process, and we also have a responsibility to these members to resolve their complaints, before the results are declared.

“We are committed to being both thorough and timely during this process.”

“We are committed to being both thorough and timely during this process.”

Durham Students’ Union

The delay comes at the end of one of the most divisive and controversial student elections in Durham’s history.

The elections were dominated by debate about the use of the Re-Open Nominations (RON) option on every ballot as a means of protesting against the SU.

A campaign supporting a RON vote was launched on Facebook hours before voting started.

The campaign advocated voting RON to protest the SU, which it accuses of running itself and the election undemocratically.

The campaign founders told Palatinate that the investigations were “reassuring”, but added: “We find it deeply concerning that the results may be withheld indefinitely by the SU. We feel that SU transparency is vital.”

Several election candidates have criticised the hostility of the campaign and voting period.

The campaign was also partly overshadowed by the withdrawal of Presidential candidate Neve Ovenden, who criticised “veiled and not-so-veiled attacks” on her and her supporters when she spoke exclusively to Palatinate.

Several election candidates have criticised the hostility of the campaign and voting period.

In a post on his Facebook campaign page, Welfare and Liberation candidate Ewan Swift wrote: “I want to use this statement to ask those behind the RON campaign to apologise to candidates for any harm caused. I, and other candidates, have had severe anxiety and panic attacks this past week.

“The SU has also let us down. The dissatisfaction with the fact that neutrality is not enforced must be addressed. We, as candidates, have been caught in the crossfire.

“I sincerely hope that should this election re-run, it is facilitated against a backdrop of kindness and empathy.”

Turnout in the election was 19.2%, which is 5% higher than last year.

Regarding the issues raised in this article, Durham SU has stated:

“Just to be clear there are two separate processes here, which we know is a little confusing. One is the review of the elections as a whole, and the other is the investigation of outstanding complaints.

“The first is the investigation of a specific formal complaint or complaints raised by a student member/s during the election. The Deputy Returning Officer can’t declare the result of the election until outstanding formal complaints from voters are resolved, but will do so once this process is complete.

“The second is the independent review of the elections by the University Secretary, which was requested by the Students’ Union before any formal complaints had been received. This a measure enacted on the second day of voting in response to student concerns which, while they had not been raised as an official complaint, were raised in the public domain by student members.  This wider review of the elections (which has a broader scope than that of specific complaints) is expected to take longer than the resolution of complaints and not delay the announcement of results. Its purpose is to highlight any issues with this election, assure voters and establish best practice for future elections.”

Image: Tim Packer from Wikimedia Commons