Students quiz Vice-Chancellor in ‘robust discussion’
Students anxious about the state of higher education in the UK, and more specifically Durham, were given the opportunity to challenge a panel of university executives and student representatives in the DSU on Monday evening.
This Question-Time set-up was presided over by DSU DUCK officer Archie Dallas who directed audience questions to a panel consisting of Durham University Vice Chancellor Professor Chris Higgins, Deputy Vice-Chancellor Anthony Forster, NUS Vice President for Higher Education Usman Ali, DSU President Mike King and DSU Education and Welfare Officer Scott Parker.
Predictably the government was first in the firing line. The opening question: “Were students really at the heart of the government white paper?”, succeeded in setting the tone of an evening in which a great concern was demonstrated over the direction and emphasis of national reform to the higher education sector.
Vice Chancellor Professor Higgins was adamant in his assertion that despite government rhetoric, students clearly came second to political compromise in the formulation of recent reforms. DSU President Mike King summed up the situation by claiming: “The white paper was a lose/lose for everybody; the government lost, academics lost, students definitely lost. Postgrads weren’t even mentioned”.
If students are at the heart of the system, Deputy Vice Chancellor Professor Forster was right to question: “Which students?”. Many MPs share the concern voiced by Usman Ali that disadvantaged students look particularly set to lose out.
Nonetheless, Universities Minister David Willets remains committed to a market-based approach to higher education provision. In response to this, students across the UK are justifiably curious as to what they can expect in return for the increased financial commitment they are required to make if they are to attend university.
Quizzing the panel as to what their £9,000 annual contribution in tuition fees will or should entitle them to, Durham students are no exception to this trend.
The panel unanimously warned of the implicit danger rooted in the notion of students as consumers. Students are not shoppers in Tesco, Vice Chancellor Higgins claimed. It is not a product they are buying but rather access into a university community.
The difficulty, he suggested, is in nailing down exactly what buys you: “Students get different things out of their student experience”.
However, this does not mean students have no right to expect improvement. Scott Parker suggested: “When we say ‘get more’ this should be in terms of quality enhancement, engagement in curriculum design and academic representation”. He did not find agreement from the University executive officers on the panel when suggesting that Durham might want to re-consider its emphasis on research.
However, general consensus was reached on the importance of making the quality of the education in Durham paramount.
As the most expensive institution in the North East, Mike King commented that students will come to Durham with high expectations. This will take many forms and questions from the audience throughout the evening stressed the poor quality of much of Durham’s student accommodation.
The Christopher block at Hilde Bede and the current plight of many St Cuthbert’s Society’s students facing the Durham winter without hot water, heating and other crucial facilities for the past seven weeks, were made to be prominent case in points.
Vice Chancellor Higgins, in an attempt to temper criticism and place a limit on student expectations, emphasised that whilst students will be paying three times as much from 2012, the University will not actually possess three times as much money.
He stated: “Money coming from students is simply replacing money that has been taken away by the government”.
Deputy Vice Chancellor Forster claimed that students would be “short-changed by conceptualising the relationship they have with universities as one based on a customer relationship”. Rather, we should see it as one of partnership.
Mike King was quick to pick up on this sentiment by suggesting that partners would be entitled to equal status in the decision making process. By contrast, he argued that the University’s decision to implement 38 week lets has been made without agreement from the student population.
As was evident from the reaction of the students present, there much opposition to this decision and its perceived knock on effects. Students fear the negative impact it might have on the ‘balance’ in our college communities and also the possible limitation of post-application residential open days.
The Vice Chancellor sought to reassure the audience by referring to the current work being done by Deputy Warden Graham Towl in trying to find a solution.
However, Mike King caught the mood of the room: “I am concerned that we don’t have answers but we do have policy”. He elaborated: “This is a perfect example of how this partnership between the University and students does not exist as it should do”.
This discussion was certainly an uncomfortable one for the Vice Chancellor and his deputy but Chris Higgins concluded the evening’s events by congratulating the DSU and its work. “You give us a hard time”, he stated, “but that’s absolutely right”.
He added: “We may not agree but these robust discussions need to be had”. Judging from the strength of opinion of those present, any future discussions look set to be very robust indeed.

