Students’ anger at Oxford Vice Chancellor’s £16,000 fee suggestion

vcphoto

By Amal Vaidya

After his call to increase tuition fees to as much as £16,000 a year, the Oxford University Vice Chancellor, Professor Hamilton, has faced strong student opposition.

In a letter signed by 23 Oxford College JCR presidents, Hamilton is criticised for wanting to put the burden of higher education funding onto students. The authors state that they “view this as a serious failure in his duty towards current and future students.”

Professor Hamilton believes that the current student fee cap does not reflect the difference in the quality of education provided by various institutions across the country.

He claims: “Given the great diversity of the institutions in our higher education system, the notion of different universities charging significantly different amounts doesn’t feel inherently unnatural.”

He notes that the current £9000 fees do not cover the expense of an Oxford undergraduate degree and feels that a type of market system, one where cost of the degree influences its price, is fair.

The signatories however disagree. They believe that Oxford will lose out on the “opportunity to attract the most able students disregarding their financial background.”

Higher fees would also have implications for Oxford’s elitist reputation.

“Oxford now has, from a low starting point, a lot of excellent work in access and outreach and a very impressive student financial support programme. All this good work would be sabotaged by a near-doubling of the tuition fee.”

The Oxford Student reported that many Oxford JCRs also had concerns.  They noted that the looming threat of higher student debt would deter applicants and criticised the market-like approach. Oxford University Student Union President, Tom Rutland, also condemned the suggestion as “unthinkable.”

Professor Hamilton also claims that while certain institutions get on “very nicely” with the current fee cap, Oxford’s academic reputation “will not endure over time” unless it manages to maintain its quality. He believes that the extra funding is required to do this.

He has also received support from the Russell group Director General, Wendy Piatt, who argues: “Our leading institutions cannot continue to be internationally competitive, provide a first-rate teaching experience and offer generous support to disadvantaged students without access to increased funding.”

However, like the JCR presidents, many believe that efforts should instead be made to lobby the government for higher education funding.

Sally Hunt, the University and College Union general secretary, commented that: “Professor Hamilton is correct to say our universities need more funding – we invest just 1.4 per cent of GDP on higher education, compared to an international average of 1.7 per cent.

“However, he is wrong to argue that students should pick up the tab when we already have the most expensive fees in Europe.”

Photograph: tejvanphotos