An Eye for an Eye

chair pic
 

By Henry Clare

“Two wrongs don’t make a right.”

These were the words emphatically asserted by my primary school teacher, after I had reciprocated the behavior of a fellow classmate by aggressively tossing the contents of my pencil case at him.

So frequently were those six words uttered in my vicinity, that it would hardly be surprising if they were engrained deep within my brain. It is evident though that others haven’t heeded that same message.

The stationary hurling incident might have been trivial, but the failure to adopt the ‘two wrongs don’t make a right’ principle can be a matter of life and death.  In parts of the USA, India, China and Indonesia, four of the world’s most populous countries, the vile act of murder is punished with…you guessed it – murder!

Not only does capital punishment disobey the most basic of human principles, it also denies the most basic of human rights- the right to life. Just as my school couldn’t take away my right to attend on the grounds of my minor misdemeanour, no state should be able to take away one’s right to life on grounds of murder.

Of course, rights need to occasionally be sacrificed as a means of punishment. But the right to life should be ever-present, and even if it isn’t, who’s to judge when, where, and for what reasons it can be taken away? Imagine the thought of such a Draconian law existing in the UK – David Cameron and Boris Johnson deciding who should face the death penalty over a bottle of Pinot Noir and a Cornish pasty (David’s favourite, of course).

I’m sure at Eton – as at my primary school – more often than not the bullies, in spite of their rugged exterior, were fragile inside. And the same goes for criminals. Those who choose to commit crimes are the people that need the most help and support from society. In prison they have the opportunity to redeem themselves, and learn their lessons.  If we actively look to construct and uphold societies that refuse to give its members a shot at retribution, then this is a failing of those societies, and humanity as a whole.

On the other side of the coin is the argument that the threat of capital punishment – just like the threat of the naughty step, of course – serves as a deterrent to potential criminals. Whilst this might sound well and good, the reality is in stark contrast. Statistics from the Death Penalty Information Centre have actually shown that in the USA, murder rates were in fact higher in those states that use the death penalty.

If we’re going to get ‘statty’ about it, there are a fair few numbers that would make any sensible man raise an eyebrow. In 2010, 130 Americans were placed on death row, and released after compelling evidence of their innocence had been dug up. If so many were wrongly accused, imagine how many innocent men and women have been – and will be – killed for crimes that they haven’t committed. Enough to raise a second eyebrow, I’d suspect.

Despite being cosigned to the realms of fiction and the big screen, ‘The Life of David Gale’ provides a compelling example of the harm that an unfair accusation can cause. Gale, who, rather ironically, spent most of life protesting against capital punishment, was sentenced to death for alleged rape and murder. By the time evidence of Gale’s innocence had been uncovered, it was too little too late, and an innocent man was dead. Gale’s case might have been fictional, but it would hardly surprise me if the capital punishment system has taken a large number of innocent lives.

So, what’s the point of the death penalty? Needless to say, it gives its victims no prospect of retributivism, nor does it deter potential criminals any more than a prison sentence and even where its victims are guilty, takes away one’s right to life. Perhaps those societies that enforce the death penalty feel that it represents revenge for criminals? But as we know, two wrongs don’t make a right.

Photograph: Flickr: megananne