Stop sneering at volunteering
By Charlotte Dick
I came across an article written in Palatinate last year entitled “DUCK expeditions are a load of quack” – admittedly a good punch line, but I found the article itself to be more a load of quack than DUCK. Whilst it made some good points about the problems voluntourism presents in our global community, it was incredibly black and white.
It’s true that voluntourism is an issue, without a doubt. White privileged Westerners travelling for a week to build a well or orphanage in central Africa does absolutely nothing for the local community and everything for our own satisfaction. How anyone can think that even a couple of weeks’ worth of work is enough to make a positive impact is beyond me. In fact, when researching the benefits of volunteering, particularly aboard, the majority merely highlight its appeal to employers, emphasising how projects will boost your CV and your mental health, none of which benefit the actual volunteering project.
JK Rowling spurred a flurry of twitter gossip when she refused to endorse a charity that provided volunteering opportunities in orphanages, commenting “I will never retweet appeals that treat poor children as opportunities to enhance westerners’ CVs.” Students, albeit with good intentions, get carried away with the idea of improving their CV with a charitable ethos, often forgetting that such expeditions reinforce patronising stereotypes about the Third World.
However, voluntourism is a specific issue that applies to specific cases of volunteering and cannot be used to generalise volunteering abroad or locally. Volunteering in other countries is not a categorical waste of time, nor is it never helpful. As Save the Children say, ‘just do your research’; ask the right questions about what organisations you are working with, what skills you can bring to it, why you are going and what the outcome will be.
I’m not talking about building an orphanage or a well but teaching English, working in refugee camps, or volunteering in hospitals if you’re a medical student
If you want to make an actual humanitarian impact, a few weeks just won’t do; you need to make a long-term commitment for changes to have a beneficial effect. But with the right organisation, the skills an intelligent and hard-working student can bring to a project are highly valuable. I’m not talking about building an orphanage or a well but teaching English, working in refugee camps, or volunteering in hospitals if you’re a medical student. There are endless opportunities that are not a load of quack and genuinely do help – you just need to find them.
DUCK offer a significant range of expeditions, all of which are carefully considered with regards to sustainability and ethics. For example, their trips to Nepal, Cambodia and Kenya are centred around teaching about water sanitation, women’s rights or the English language, all of which are valuable. Whilst I would argue the expeditions would be far more constructive if they were longer than a few weeks, this does not mean their input is not valuable.
I find it bleak and narrow-minded to assume that all volunteering abroad has no value anymore. One of the huge benefits is cross-cultural experiences and communication; in an increasingly globalised world, it is so important for future leaders to experience what different cultures are actually like! Whilst Durham is an excellent university full of ambitious and bright students, no one has failed to notice the lack of diversity in our privileged bubble.
In an increasingly globalised world, it is so important for future leaders to experience what different cultures are actually like
DUCK offers one of the few opportunities for students to escape this bubble and gain an understanding of other cultures, languages and people – why is this a bad thing? One of the dominant issues in international diplomacy is a lack of empathy for the cultural and historical factors that influence politics. If more people had experiences that stimulated discussions about racism, colonialism, different religions and political structures, it could only be beneficial for future global relations.
My own anecdote is my experience working with Syrian refugees in Durham. Yes, it is rewarding, but that’s the least of my reasons for doing it. Whilst this is local volunteering, I have learnt so much about Middle Eastern culture, traditions and faiths, most of which contradict the stereotypes propounded by the Western media. Without such an experience I would not have the knowledge I do now to argue for the rights of refugees and against discrimination towards Islamic culture.
Volunteering is positive. Voluntourism is not – but they are not the same thing. Be bold with your choices and do not let other people dissuade you from challenging yourself to help others. Just make sure your help will actually be beneficial, and that you’re going for the right reasons – then your work will be worthwhile, selfless and meaningful.
Image by Mark Doliner via Flickr Creative Commons
