Stokes’ controversial dismissal overshadows England’s ongoing batting frailties

Picture600x400

By Kishan Vaghela 

Australia took control of the five-match one-day international series against England with a 64-run victory at Lord’s. However, the result was overshadowed by the dismissal of Ben Stokes, who was adjudged to have obstructed the field by blocking Mitchell Starc’s throw at the stumps whilst struggling to return to his crease.

A sense of déjà vu ensued at the beginning of the day, as England once again put Australia into bat, whilst Steve Smith continued his rich vein of form in this calendar year, contributing 70 runs from 87 balls to Australia’s eventual 309-7. Even more reassuring will be the 54 made by former Australian ODI captain George Bailey, who has had a torrid year, as a lack of form saw him miss out on Australia regaining the World Cup in home conditions. Unfortunately for the visitors, David Warner, who has been replaced by fellow destructive opener Aaron Finch in the squad, is likely to miss the remainder of the series following a broken thumb sustained from a Steven Finn bouncer. Nevertheless, his early departure from the field did not hinder Australia in accumulating a score in excess of 300, with all-rounder Mitchell Marsh (64) and explosive batsman Glenn Maxwell (49) helping to propel the visitors above the cricketing safe haven in days gone by.

However, yet another score above 300 proved to be enough for Australia, just as it was in the first ODI in Southampton, as batting in the middle overs was once again England’s Achilles heel, as 141-4 soon enough became 187-8. Unsurprisingly however, it was the obstructing the field dismissal of Ben Stokes which overshadowed the fleeting innings of Moeen Ali, Jos Buttler and Stokes himself. Having played a defensive shot straight back to the bowler Starc, Stokes attempted to regain his ground, only to block Starc’s effort at the stumps with his outstretched left arm. It was left to TV umpire Joel Wilson to decide the Durham all-rounder’s fate, and having been consulted by on-field umpires Kumar Dharmasena and Tim Robinson, decided that Stokes had “wilfully” obstructed the field, as stated in Law 37. The decision turned a seemingly imperturbable crowd into a hostile one, with replays possibly demonstrating that Stokes was protecting himself from the throw rather than intentionally preventing the throw from crashing into the stumps.

Mitchell Starc’s dropped catch from an Eoin Morgan reverse sweep did put a smile back on some of the England supporters’ faces, before their seminal support brought about a late flurry of boundaries from Morgan and Liam Plunkett, who recorded a 65-run partnership from just 19 balls in the process. Nevertheless, it was Starc who enjoyed the last laugh, as his full-length delivery crashed into Plunkett’s stumps to break the partnership before Cummins had Morgan caught at long-off to seal a second successive victory.

Another emphatic win for the world champions, but England must address their middle order batting, particularly with internationally callow top order batsmen Alex Hales, Jason Roy and James Taylor failing to build partnerships or make significant scores. Tiredness is undoubtedly a feature, but Buttler and Stokes look a shadow of the free-flowing players who were so influential in the ODI series earlier in the summer against New Zealand. With Joe Root still to return to the side, the pressure on Buttler and Stokes to perform with the bat is greater, and therefore their return to form is fundamental if England are to turn the series around in the next three matches.

Photograph: Dan Heap via Wikimedia Commons