Klopp for the Kop?

By Kishan Vaghela

Juergen_Klopp

Regardless of the situation in focus, a certain cliché is always relevant; circumstances change extremely quickly. Rewind a year and Liverpool were emerging as favourites for the title, a trophy that had so far evaded them in the Premier League’s short 13-year history. Back in the present day and some have called for Brendan Rodgers’ sacking after their elimination from England’s most historic competition, the FA Cup, by Aston Villa. Five days previous to their elimination, news broke in Germany that Jürgen Klopp would be leaving Borussia Dortmund after their below-par season, which has seen ‘Die Schwarzgelben’ hover around the relegation zone before and after the winter break. Nevertheless, the nature of football automatically lays the blame at the doorstep of the manager, and whilst Rodgers is by no means guiltless, Liverpool’s problems lay deeper than a man who almost managed to win England’s biggest prize last season.

Undoubtedly, a man who has won back-to-back league titles in a league in which Bayern Munich compete is an achievement in itself. In comparison with Rodgers, who will now endure his third trophyless season at Anfield, it seems simple as to why supporters would prefer to see the German take over the reins. Nevertheless, beneath the surface lay issues that Klopp has become accustomed to during his time in the Bundesliga, and has ultimately led to his departure from the club in the North Rhine-Westphalia state. Mention the names Mario Götze and Robert Lewandowski to Dortmund fans and the same stern face Arsenal fans would greet you with if the name Robin Van Persie was muttered would appear. Whilst Bayern Munich continue to be the Bundesliga’s most prominent team, Klopp ultimately failed to appease the nucleus of his side, resulting in their departures. With Klopp having departed, the futures of Mats Hummels, Īlkay Gündoğan and Marco Reus will be uncertain in the summer. Were Klopp to arrive at Anfield, he could potentially face a similar exodus. Jordan Henderson is yet to sign a new deal with Liverpool, whilst the Raheem Sterling saga has rumbled on enough to have provoked Liverpool’s mini collapse in the second half of this season. Liverpool cannot be considered as England’s second best team at present, and therefore interest in England and in Europe with regards to the 20-year-old may only be matched by interest in France international Paul Pogba. Could Klopp convince Sterling to stay? The last time he managed a 20-year-old star in the making, his release clause was triggered and Bayern Munich acquired a man who, a year later, would score the winner in the World Cup final. Certainly food for thought.

Not only does the nature of football lay blame heavily on the manager after a poor string of results, but similarly his positive effect on the club and the players’ performances instantly vanish from memory. Liverpool fans may frown at the signing of Mario Balotelli for £16m and Dejan Lovren for £20m. But Klopp fared little better in replacing the core of his team. Shinji Kagawa hasn’t looked anywhere near the player who was sold to Manchester United three years ago. In replacing Lewandowski, the German brought in Ciro Immobile and Adrián Ramos, who have a combined total of five league goals in 32 league appearances. Jürgen Klopp has also failed to bring any youth players from Dortmund’s academy into the first team, with the careers of hopefuls such as Erik Durm and Jonas Hofmann having stalled. On the contrary to Klopp, it has been forgotten that it was the Northern Irishman Rodgers who put his faith in Daniel Sturridge, not only by acquiring his services in 2013, but by yielding performances from him which consequently led him to be considered as one of the best strikers in this country. Additionally, it was Rodgers who gave Sterling his entry into the first team, and whilst Sterling’s talent was recognised by former manager Rafael Benitez who brought him to Anfield, young players desperately require a manager whose belief in his players is unquestionable. Some will question Rodgers’ ability to retain the quality of player that a club of Liverpool’s magnitude deserves, such as Luis Suárez. Barcelona may be equally as big a club as Bayern Munich, but £75m for a player who has had issues on the field through various biting incidents, compared to £35m for a player who still had the best years of his career ahead of him and was a lot younger than Suárez at the time of his sale, demonstrates that Klopp would also have struggled and even may have come off worse were he in charge last summer. In addition, he failed to even acquire a fee for Robert Lewandowski. Borussia Dortmund were by no means a side in transition at the points of Götze and Lewandowski’s sales, as they are now. Liverpool most certainly are, and Brendan Rodgers seems to have systems in place to deal with the situation rather than walk away.

Brendan Rodgers

Dortmund have not been distracted by contract sagas or a possible fairytale departure for their captain who has the third highest appearances in the club’s history. Marco Reus put an end to speculation over his future by signing a new deal until 2019 before the announcement regarding Klopp’s departure. Raheem Sterling is yet to do that for Liverpool. Klopp has clearly failed to sustain Dortmund’s rivalry with Bayern Munich, and with clubs in England such as Chelsea, Manchester City, Manchester United and Arsenal possessing more financial power than their German counterparts, it is difficult to see how Klopp would consistently challenge for the title in England. There are certainly managers who could build on the platform Rodgers has built, but the man from Northern Ireland deserves longer to convert that into trophies.

Photographs: Wikipedia