Role reversal as England thrash sorry India
By Kishan Vaghela
Brisbane has not been a happy hunting ground for India this winter. Having lost the Test Match in the series against Australia in Queensland’s most populous city, which preceded the current Tri-Series, India were once again comprehensively beaten by nine wickets at the same ground, this time by England in a One Day International (ODI).
Having won the toss, India put themselves into bat, only to watch the brilliance of Steven Finn and James Anderson unravel before their eyes.  Finn took his best ODI figures of 5-33, whilst Anderson claimed 4-18 on his return from a knee injury to restrict India to 153 in less than 40 overs. England chased the target inside 28 overs to claim a bonus point, helped by an unbeaten 88 from Ian Bell and James Taylor’s 56 not out. The result leaves England in second position behind Australia in the table, who meet on Friday. Undoubtedly this was a morale boosting win for England, but how much will both sides read into such a game, with less than a month remaining before the beginning of the World Cup?
England most certainly will take a lot of heart from such a display. Steven Finn’s best ODI figures ironically came in the same city where a year ago he was declared “non-selectable”, and upon becoming only the second Englishman to pick up 5 wickets in an ODI in Australia, England can certainly, as Steven Finn wants to, “look forward, not back”. James Anderson’s contribution can only be a positive after swinging the ball both ways with extreme accuracy, highlighted by conceding only one run off three overs from the bat. More encouraging was how this partnership has the potential to create problems on the pacy and bouncy Australian wickets against every nation competing in the World Cup. On the batting front, Ian Bell was amongst the runs and therefore puts to bed any debate of whether he should be part of the England ODI set-up. Bell simultaneously moved closer to the England record of most ODI runs of 5,092 held by Paul Collingwood, with his 88 moving him up to 4,995. James Taylor’s rise in ODI cricket continued, his average of 45.20 since being recalled to the squad is testament to this.

The same positivity cannot be expressed for India. Having collapsed to 67-5 after four wickets for just 10 runs in 28 balls, there was a small recovery from Mahendra Singh Dhoni and controversial World Cup inclusion Stuart Binny. However, it was the short ball that ended that partnership and lead ultimately to India’s demise. The likes of Virat Kohli, Shikhar Dhawan and Ajinkya Rahane all failed to contribute, undoubtedly a huge factor in such a low score being posted, with the last five wickets being lost for only 16 runs.  Poor shot selection and the constant inability to play against quick and short bowling was India’s downfall, but their bowling was equally poor. Although not having a target to bowl at, the ability to only take one wicket was a cause for concern. India’s bowlers have been criticised in the longer format for not being able to take 20 wickets, and the same criticism could be aimed at them in the shorter format. Wasim Akram was heavily critical, expressing his surprise at Stuart Binny opening the bowling when defending such a low total.  Sunil Gavaskar was more cautious in criticising India, blaming “a lot of experimentation”, whilst stating that “a different frame of mind” will set in by the time the World Cup begins. What will be most interesting is India’s pace combination in their next game, with Ishant Sharma, Mohammed Shami, Bhuvneshwar Kumar, Stuart Binny and Umesh Yadav all in the frame.
Akram and Gavaskar perfectly described the situation. The former said “This was a Tri-Series fixture, not a practice match”, whilst the latter stated how “Winning is a habit, but so is losing”. Both statements will be need to be remembered for both sides if they are to progress from this, progress which will most likely determine how both sides fair in the World Cup.
Photograph: commons.wikimedia
