Stereotyping politicians must not distract us from key issues

by Francesca Moll

A couple of weeks ago, BBC’s hit TV show, The Thick of It, saw ineffectual opposition leader Nicola Murray deposed by the machinations of Malcolm Tucker while on a nightmarish train journey to Bradford.  It has been observed that this series of Armando Ianucci’s political satire has been predicting real-life political events with uncanny accuracy – the abolition of breakfast clubs and the setting up of a community bank to name a couple.  And now it seems the Curse of Tucker has struck a third time, with Nicola Murray’s train fiasco mirrored by George Osborne’s debacle last month as he returned from visiting his constituency in Tatton, Cheshire.

While I would be the first to seize the opportunity to laugh at the snobbery of the current government, I can’t help but be left cold by the furore created by the press at the time. My instinctive reaction was very much a ‘so what?’

Now, don’t get me wrong. I’m not a closet Tory, nor do I have any wish to defend snobbery and elitism in government.  But for me, this was nowhere near as big a deal as Andrew Mitchell’s abusive tirade at a police officer.  I mean, it’s really quite easy to sit in the first-class sections of some trains by mistake.

Clearly, that’s not what happened here, but what’s so wrong about wanting to upgrade when standard class is clearly full?  A senior cabinet minister may have sensitive information to discuss which requires a less crowded, more peaceful environment. Of course, I wouldn’t advocate special privileges for those in government as a rule, but in the context of a crowded train and a long day visiting his constituency, Osborne’s actions are perhaps more comprehensible.

To be honest, there’s not even any agreement that George Osborne really did express any sentiment about ‘it not being possible’ for him to move and slum it with the ordinary people in standard class. Virgin Trains denies that the Chancellor made any fuss about paying the extra money, and all accounts agree that it was an aide who spoke with the ticket inspector, not Osborne himself. It hardly seems fair to damn a man for the behaviour of his staff.

But all that aside, what bothered me most about the whole issue was its relative insignificance in the grand scheme of things. There are many things that one could lampoon Osborne for: welfare cuts, the ideological shrinkage of the public sector or the widespread culture of tax avoidance by the rich.

Instead though, the press chose to resort to a crude game of old Etonian (or indeed, old Pauline) whack-a-mole. How can we hope to intelligently debate controversial Tory policies if we can’t get past the childish point-scoring that seems to pervade discussion of the current government?

Yes, it is highly amusing when hated public figures play up to stereotypes.  But tempting as it is, we cannot let this become our focus. Let’s leave the comedy to The Thick of It.