Sports Personality of the Year: a celebration of British sport 

By Joseph Barnett

In 1954, Winston Churchill was Prime Minister, there was only one (black and white) television channel in existence, and the England cricket team travelled three weeks by boat to reach Australia for the Ashes (a far cry from the speed and convenience of modern air travel).  

1954 was also the year that the BBC established the programme Sports Review of the Year in response to the growing desire for people to watch the biggest sporting moments of the year on their televisions (rather than listen to them over the radio).  

The programme was conceived to survey the year’s sporting action and to recognise the achievements of sportspeople. The show has always culminated with the award of the BBC Sports Personality of the Year, given to the athlete who most captures the imagination of the public. Other awards have since been added such as the Team of the Year in 1960 and the Helen Rollason Award in 1998 which celebrates achievement in the face of adversity.  


The programme was conceived to survey the year’s sporting action and to recognise the achievements of sportspeople

The media landscape has changed beyond recognition since 1954 and the BBC’s coverage of sport on television is severely diminished from its heyday in the 1980s. However, BBC Sports Personality of the Year (the award now gives its name to the wider programme) remains part of the rhythms of the sporting year and has retained its prestige.  

This fundamental truth was shown again at this year’s ceremony. Despite living in Florida, Rory McIlroy made the effort to attend the show in the week before Christmas, referencing how he watched the programme throughout his childhood in his winner’s speech. Even in a world where public service broadcasting is increasingly viewed as an anachronism, BBC Sports Personality of the Year (SPOTY) still has the power to bridge across generations and shape the national conversation.  

The SPOTY awards have been a constant companion to sport enthusiasts over the past 70 years, and the award has always been determined by a vote from the public. This is because the BBC wanted the award to reflect the views of the ordinary fan rather than journalists or experts.  

At times, public voting could lead to unpredictable outcomes and controversy. In 1991, the BBC had to step in and remove angler Bob Nunn from the shortlist because executives feared that a fisherman would win the award. Such was the effectiveness of the Angling Times campaign.  

The SPOTY awards have been a constant companion to sport enthusiasts over the past 70 years, and the award has always been determined by a vote from the public

In recent years, some members of the public have become frustrated with the voting system. The shortlist of athletes was cut from twelve to six, meaning that the public have a narrower selection of sportspeople to choose from. Some feel that this has undermined the spirit of the awards by placing more power in the hands of the expert panel who choose the shortlist, despite the premise claiming to be centred on public, not expert opinion.  

The technology underpinning the public vote has changed over the years. Initially, the public voted via postcard and for many years the winner of Sports Personality of the Year would need to be nominated through a form in the Radio Times. Voting is now conducted via the BBC website (phone voting was discontinued after the 2024 ceremony) leading to complaints that this marginalises the views of older viewers who are less adept at using technology.  

The 2025 award was deservedly won by Rory McIlroy. He was the first golfer to win since Nick Faldo in 1989. McIlroy’s thrilling triumph at The Masters in April made him only the sixth man, and first European, to win the career Grand Slam. McIlroy also played a crucial role in Europe’s underdog victory at the Ryder Cup in New York. Second place went to Ellie Kildunne – the star of the Red Roses’ home World Cup win – who continues the successful run for sportswomen in recent years as women’s sport continues to thrive.  

When looking at past winners of the award, it is clear to see that some years are more competitive than others. Olympic years are particularly hard-fought due to the wide array of gold-medal winners that Team GB have produced at the past few games.  

Despite winning two gold medals at the London 2012 Olympics, Mo Farah did not even finish inside the top 3, although he did go on to claim the 2017 prize. Given the stranglehold that football has over British sport throughout most of the year, it is surprising that only seven winners have been footballers.  

However, this probably reflects the public’s preference for individual sportspeople as shown by the success of boxers (Barry McGuigan – 1985, Lennox Lewis – 1999, Joe Calzaghe – 2007), Formula 1 drivers (Nigel Mansel – 1986, 1992; Damon Hill – 1994, 1996; Lewis Hamilton – 2014, 2020) and tennis players (Virginia Wade – 1977; Greg Rudeski – 1997; Andy Murray – 2013, 2015, 2016; Emma Raducanu – 2022). Members of the Royal Family have also found success at the BBC event with Princess Anne and her daughter both taking the title for equestrian.  

Overall, BBC Sports Personality of the Year will always illicit controversy and it is an event that the tabloids love to hate. The show is not perfect however it does provide the nation with an appropriate opportunity to celebrate the achievement of sportspeople while reviewing the year’s major sporting events. It’s undoubtedly an indispensable part of the BBC’s television offering in the run up to Christmas.  

Image by Parrot of Doom via Wikimedia Commons