Have sports fans finally taken it too far?
By Joseph Barnett
Sport is often said to be ‘the most important thing of the least important things’ in life, and although this phrase is somewhat of a cliché pulled out by the earnest commentator when sport becomes entwined with tragedy, I do think it does ring true for many people. Life is inherently uncertain, filled with challenge, struggle, and disappointment. Supporting a team or sportsperson offers an enjoyable escape from life’s stresses, coupled with a sense of belonging. The large majority of sporting enthusiasts would identify with this description about what it is to be a fan; unfortunately, a growing minority are overstepping the mark and abusing the privileged position of a spectator to spread abuse.
Golf is considered a gentlemen’s game where sportsmanship is sacrosanct, and the crowds are deferential. The Ryder Cup is an exception to this rule. The team event is well known for its tribal atmosphere and raucous crowds, and these two factors have been important in making the Ryder Cup so commercially successful.
Support for Europe and America in the event has become tied up with ideas of national prestige and there are militaristic undertones to the proceedings: the 1991 Ryder Cup was called ‘the War on the Shore’ and American Golfers wore Khaki ‘Desert Storm’ caps in tribute to soldiers from that year’s Gulf War. Poor fan behaviour has reared its ugly head over the years – most notably in the 1999 Ryder Cup in Brookline, New York, when fan abuse of the European players and their families was unrelenting.
Poor fan behaviour (in the Ryder Cup) has reared its head over the years
The cocktail of a tribal atmosphere, constant nationalistic posturing, and flowing alcohol is a nasty one, and therefore it was no surprise that fan abuse was particularly problematic in this year’s edition. On the second day of play, fan behaviour deteriorated and the crowd became a baying mob: the European team received all kinds of offensive and witless insults (45-year-old Justin Rose was called a ‘Grandpa’) but the worst of the onslaught was suffered by Rory McIlroy and Shane Lowry who were thrown constant barbs all through their round. Eventually, the Irish duo threatened to stop playing when shouting prevented McIlroy from putting, normally an activity that a golfer undertakes in silence. Play only continued after Justin Thomas, McIlroy’s American opponent, stepped in to quiet the crowd.
The scenes from that weekend were deeply unedifying – it was hard to escape the conclusion that the adversarial nature of the contest had been taken too far. The organisers undoubtedly contributed to the mess. They made a virtue of the fact before the event that the atmosphere would be ‘completely chaotic’ and the Event PA led the crowds in the chant, “F*** you, Rory”, hardly setting a good example to the crowd. The offending fans must also feel ashamed: watching sport is about supporting your side positively, especially at golf events where you are so physically close to the action.
Unfortunately, this is not just an ‘American’ problem or ‘golf’s’ problem but a growing issue across the world of sport. Luke Littler has faced constant taunts on stage whilst at the oche, particularly when playing at events in Germany, a centre of darts in Europe. Whilst this is unacceptable, it can be attributed to national rivalry. More inexplicable is the rise of abuse for Littler at venues in this country as shown throughout this year’s Premier League. Littler is one of Britain’s most remarkable young sporting talents, only last week winning the World Grand Prix. His plight shows more needs to be done to stamp out this fan disorder.
Unfortunately, this is not just an ‘American’ problem or ‘golf’s’ problem but a growing issue across the world of sport
In the case of darts and the Ryder Cup, alcohol does play a role in explaining people’s actions and therefore if things don’t improve, alcohol should be restricted as is the case in football grounds. To find the ‘nuclear’ option for dealing with unruly fans, we can look to history because between 1985 and 1990, English clubs were banned by UEFA from European club football in response to hooliganism. Whilst at this point, this step seems premature or unworkable (holding a Ryder Cup without fans would be absurd), if things decline further, administrators should not be afraid to use this weapon.
When taking their seats in the stand or arena, supporters must remember the phrase that began this article. In the scheme of life and death, sport is fundamentally unimportant: a game, not a war and sportspeople are human beings, not punching bags.
Image Credit: Bryan Berlin via Wikimedia Commons

