Spare won’t win the War of the Windsors – it evens it out
By Florence Clifford
Like them or loathe them, it feels impossible to avoid the royal family currently. This has only intensified with the recent publication of Prince Harry’s ghost- written memoir, Spare.
Spare isn’t afraid to pull punches, castigating the royal family and portraying palace courtiers as slimy sycophants. Harry’s main gripe, encapsulated in the book’s title, is with being treated throughout his life as a throwaway second child, according to traditional royal hierarchy. The mediaeval relic of the ‘heir and spare’ idea highlights the separation between the royal family as “institution”, as Harry calls it, and the royal family as people.
Spare isn’t afraid to pull punches
Harry pleaded emotionally in an interview pre-publication that “I would like my father… and brother back,” but what he wants back are “Pa” and “Willy”, not King Charles III and the Prince of Wales. Harry’s current source of suffering is that his nearest and dearest have chosen the institution over the family. The lesson is that you can’t have both.
Spare makes that divide between the public and personal real. There is undeniable tragedy here, most obviously the trauma of Harry losing his mother at age twelve, which haunts the memoir. Equally, elements of the book are absurd, from the story of Harry losing his virginity, to William pushing him into a dog bowl and leaving him to pick shards of china out of his back.
Spare makes a family that was revered as God’s representatives on Earth look like a troupe of clowns. We’re watching the messy divorce of the country’s most overprivileged family. One of the most ludicrous moments is the princes’ quarrel over charitable causes. “Africa is my thing, you can’t have it,” William says petulantly, reducing all the Windsors’ charity work to kids scrapping over the last Quality Street at Christmas.
More importantly, fighting over Africa like a pair of old colonial empires hardly helps the monarchy’s defence of itself as “not a racist family,” as William has claimed.
One thing the book will do for certain is ensure that the surrounding hysteria won’t die down. Conspiracy theorists would be forgiven for imagining that Harry has cut a deal with the media he so despises to keep churning out content like this. It keeps the royalties coming in for him and provides gossip columnists with easy jobs — everyone wins.
Spare is unlikely to silence Harry’s doubters. Eyebrows will be raised over the wisdom of publicising intimate family arguments and admitting his Afghanistan kill count, thereby putting a Taliban target on his back. This is especially so given his well- documented anger at invasions of privacy and lack of paid-for security.
Equally, the Sussexes do have a right to tell their side of the story, and it must be frustrating for Harry that Buckingham Palace have thus far refused to respond. The dignified silence from Windsor HQ serves the added purpose of making Harry look immature, which somewhat reinforces his point that that’s what they’ve deliberately done his whole life.
Harry’s revelations get at one of the fundamentals of Britishness: the attitude of stiff upper lip, getting on with things no matter how awful they might be. Given the princes’ bereavement at a young age and its damaging impact on him, Harry dumps his trauma into a lucrative book deal. It is hard to argue that the royal family’s silent approach is any better.
Harry dumps his trauma into a lucrative book deal
Ultimately, the idea of dividing the public into pro-royal family or pro-Harry-and-Megs completely misses the point. You can feel sympathy for Harry’s traumatising childhood, and the undeniable racism and nastiness thrown at Meghan, while also thinking they’re self-serving and entitled.
Setting the two perspectives in conflict ignores how they aren’t mutually exclusive, benefiting the press machine which profits from this division and anger. It prevents productive conversations occurring about the nature of the British royal family.
It seems incredibly apparent that the whole dysfunctional family would be happier living normal lives as ordinary people, with the added benefit that we wouldn’t have to listen to any of their nonsense. And the final (and unintentional) message of Spare is that we are probably better off without them.
Image credit: Northern Ireland Office via Wikimedia Commons

