Going round in circles: Vegas Loop and public transport

By Becks Fleet

Let me ask you a question: How do you get people around a busy city, quickly & easily without congestion, whilst hiding all the infrastructure underground? Most of the world has pretty universally answered that question using a humble, centuries-old technology: the train. However, Las Vegas has decided that the answer to that question isn’t the classic, economical, eco-friendly train, but an underground road network where Tesla electric cars drive, one by one, in a system of tunnels that currently needs an individual driver for each vehicle but might be driverless one day, maybe, possibly, potentially. Oh yeah, and it cost over $48 million (so far) to build.

While we in the UK are blessed with a huge and comprehensive train network (even if the government has no idea how to operate it), our friends over the pond don’t benefit from the same amenities; Amtrack, the US’ main passenger railroad network, only provides good coverage in urban areas on the east & west coast, and doesn’t even pass through two entire states. Instead, the only real way to travel across the US outside of the urban cities is by car, the most American of American ways to travel across America. Even within the cities, huge highways often dominate the landscape and, in the vast suburbs, a car is often a must-have if you want to travel anywhere beyond the end of your street.

It’s almost cartoonishly bad, and downright embarrassing

The proposed Tesla-based tunnel transportation system in Las Vegas, called a “Loop” by its builders The Boring Company (owned by Elon Musk as one of his many, many pet projects), was trialled during the recent CES convention held in Vegas. The Boring Company claims that the tunnels are “safe, fast-to-dig, and low cost”, and are designed to “solve traffic, enable rapid point-to-point transportation and transform cities”. They also make the questionable claim that the only way to solve traffic is for roads to “go 3D”, conveniently ignoring the existence of transportation options that don’t involve cars. How very stereotypically American of them.

During the CES trial, it immediately had a number of glaring issues; according to Jalopnik, each car needed an individual driver (despite Tesla’s reassurances that the system will eventually use driverless vehicles), each station needed dozens of employees to stop the whole system from falling apart, some riders were taken to the wrong destination, and parts of the line were even abruptly closed, leaving users who relied on it stranded. Basically, it’s like if you combined the worst aspects of travelling by car, the worst aspects of travelling by train, shoved them together and wasted millions of dollars making it unfortunately real. It’s almost cartoonishly bad, and downright embarrassing for the city that they allowed this to be built over an actual, useful system, such as a train or metro network.

Worst of all is that Vegas already has a far superior (albeit flawed) public transportation system: a monorail network. Besides it just looking really cool – far better than the gaudy neon of the Loop tunnels – it’s much more efficient at taking passengers across the city in a quick, reliable and environmentally friendly fashion. Of course, this provides a threat to Musk’s proposal, and although the monorail system is fairly short and has run into financial difficulties in the past, investment into the monorail network surely makes a lot more sense than Musk’s half-baked system of not-driverless driverless cars in a tunnel. On top of this, the proposals for the Loop system, if fully built, apparently run the risk of damaging the support structures of the monorail, as the tunnels are planned to go directly below the monorail track. What a great idea.

A perfect demonstration of America’s unwavering […] commitment to the car

The fact that Vegas has allowed this dreadful concept – a billionaire’s ill-advised vanity project – to actually become reality is a perfect demonstration of America’s unwavering, questionable commitment to the car as the only real form of transportation. Why build a train network, when you can build a network of cars that act identically to trains but are significantly less efficient and reliable? Apparently Vegas is convinced.

Image: Steve Jurvetson, CC BY 2.0 [cropped]