South College Principal opposes plans to build a care home next door
By Becks Fleet
Palatinate has learned that a planning application has been submitted to Durham County Council for a new 74-bed care home to be built on “undeveloped grass land” on Mount Oswald next to South and John Snow Colleges.
The application for the 4420 square metre site, submitted by Torsion Care Ltd in August, details plans for a three-storey building and a 23-space car park. They say that the development will create 75 new jobs.
The City of Durham Trust has released a statement in support of the development. They claim, “The Durham city area will need additional care beds in future due to demographic trends” and that the “Neighbourhood Plan paragraph 4.324 describes the anticipated future need and concludes that it will be necessary either to expand existing care homes or to build new ones. This is the basis for the Trust’s support in principle for the proposal.”
“I fear the possibility of conflict between student lifestyles and the expectations of families placing their aged relatives in residential care”
south college principal, tim luckhurst
However, the proposal has also seen opposition – particularly from Tim Luckhust, the Principal of South College.
In a public letter opposing the development, Prof. Luckhurst said that: “I am concerned that a care home and a university college may not be the happiest of neighbours. South College is home to 492 students, the large majority of whom are undergraduates. Approximately 700 additional students of Durham University are members of South College.
“Every year we host events including matriculation, graduation, college days, remembrance day, formal dinners, college balls, fashion shows and drama performances. Each attracts large numbers of students, and some are accompanied by live and/or amplified music. The houses at Mount Oswald were distanced from our buildings precisely because such events were anticipated and understood. This distancing has worked well, and noise pollution rarely disturbs our existing neighbours.”
He continued, “The proposed care home will be directly opposite South College, closer than any of the existing private residences. I fear the possibility of conflict between student lifestyles and the expectations of families placing their aged relatives in residential care. Plainly, I am anxious to ensure that South College students can continue to enjoy student life without inconveniencing or disturbing any neighbours.”
“We actually have an overprovision of Older Persons Care Home beds in County Durham”
county durham care partnership
The County Durham Care Partnership have also opposed the development.
The partnership said: “We actually have an overprovision of Older Persons Care Home beds in County Durham […] there are already 2 large new Older Persons Care Homes being built in County Durham with anticipated completion dates in 2023.”
They also noted that the proposed development’s “location near to large student accommodation is not ideal due to noise issues. Older People often prefer to go to bed early and we would suggest that the student lifestyle doesn’t align with that.”
The proposal is currently pending consideration, with Durham County Council yet to make a decision.
Image: TSP via Wikimedia Commons
