South Africa’s Agony: Apartheid’s haunting legacy

By Amine Gherensi

On 11 February 1990, Nelson Mandela was released from Victor Verster Prison, ushering in a period of hope and reconciliation upon being elected to the presidency in 1994. This period culminated in the 2010 FIFA World Cup, showcasing the country’s potential as a thriving democracy. However, this optimism has since faded, replaced by economic hardship, political instability, and widespread public discontent. In 2024, the African National Congress (ANC) suffered a historical electoral defeat, losing its parliamentary majority for the first time since 1994. Once seen as synonymous with South Africa’s liberation struggle, the ANC is now associated with corruption, failing infrastructure, and a deepening economic crisis.

The country is grappling with worsening infrastructural challenges, including rolling blackouts, water shortages, and failing public services. The South African Institution of Civil Engineering (SAICE) has warned that many roads, hospitals, and water systems are on the brink of collapse; some are already deemed “unfit for use”. Meanwhile, Eskom, the state-owned electricity provider, has been unable to meet demands, making power cuts a daily reality. The economic situation is just as bleak, with GDP growth averaging just 1% per year since 2010. When adjusted for population growth, GDP per capita has declined, meaning South Africans are worse off financially today than a decade ago. In 2024, South Africa also had the highest youth unemployment rate in the G20, fueling an alarming spike in crime, and placing the country among the top five globally for overall crime rates and the top ten for intentional homicides. With the police force underfunded and overstretched, conviction rates are low, with only around 20% of murder cases leading to a conviction. As a result, many citizens have turned to private security, which now outnumbers both police officers and soldiers combined. This has widened economic inequality; only the wealthy can afford protection, leaving millions vulnerable and distrustful of the government.

The country is grappling with worsening infrastructural challenges, including rolling blackouts, water shortages, and failing public services

At the heart of South Africa’s struggles is systemic corruption within the ANC, which has crippled key state institutions and economic stability. The Zondo Commission exposed how public funds were looted through cronyism, patronage networks, and political interference. The Gupta family scandal, in which former President Jacob Zuma allegedly enabled state looting, became the defining example of ANC corruption. State-owned enterprises (SOEs) such as Eskom, South African Airways, and Transnet have been plundered by ANC-aligned elites, causing billions in financial losses. At Eskom alone, corruption costs over £40 million per month, deepening the country’s electricity crisis. Meanwhile, Skilled engineers have been replaced by political appointees, further deepening inefficiencies. Despite President Cyril Ramaphosa’s promises of reform, corruption remains deeply entrenched, with ANC leadership protecting implicated officials. This culture of impunity was a major factor behind the party’s electoral failure in 2024.

As the ANC weakens, opposition parties gain traction. In 2024, uMkhonto we Sizwe (MK), the newly formed populist party of Jacob Zuma, secured 14.6% of the national vote, severely damaging the ANC’s stronghold in KwaZulu-Natal. MK accuses the ANC of betraying its liberation ideals and failing to uplift the Black working class. Meanwhile, the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), led by Julius Malema, continues to present itself as a radical alternative. The EFF advocates radical land reform, nationalisation, and economic redistribution with Malema arguing that the ANC has become too moderate and corporate-aligned, failing to deliver economic justice.

In an effort to win back support, the ANC has embraced more aggressive redistribution policies, such as the Expropriation Act, which allows the government to seize land deemed “in the public interest” without compensation. The ANC claims this will promote economic equality and correct historical injustices. However, critics argue that the Act risks economic collapse, threatens property rights, and discourages investment. The vast majority of commercial farmland remains in white ownership, raising fears that expropriation could destabilise food production. Some compare it to Zimbabwe’s land seizures under Robert Mugabe, which triggered economic collapse, hyperinflation, and mass food shortages. There are also serious concerns about corruption in land redistribution. Many fear ANC elites will benefit, while ordinary citizens see little improvement. Moreover, figures like Julius Malema call for more radical redistribution while stoking racial tensions with the controversial chant, “kill the Boer, kill the farmer.” The rise in farm murders has only deepened fears of targeted violence, with critics accusing the ANC of failing to protect vulnerable communities.

As South Africa nears half a century of post-apartheid democracy, it stands at a turning point. Mr Mandela’s vision of a united, prosperous Rainbow Nation has been overshadowed by economic hardship, corruption, and political instability. The ANC’s decline has paved the way for populist challengers, but whether these new forces bring reform or deepen the crisis remains unclear. The 2024 election signals a shifting political landscape, yet without meaningful reform.

Image Credit: Dietmar Rabich/Wikimedia Commons