Should the government lift the cap on tuition fees?
The current university tuition fees in the UK are only a fraction of the overall cost for an individual to spend three or more years studying for a degree. The remainder of the cost, which is not included in the fees paid out by students or their loans each year, are subsidised by the government, and therefore the taxpayer.
Both the government and people of Britain, however, pride themselves on the existence of an education system which is available to everyone. This refers to our state school system, which despite its various problems allows all the opportunity to learn.
But this ethos of education for all should include higher education for those who have the potential, and the desire to pursue that potential. Those who are capable should not have to make the decision of whether they are to continue their education beyond the age of eighteen on the basis of affordability.
Repeated proposals have been made to raise the cap on tuition fees in the United Kingdom, but now the government is making suggestions of following in the footsteps of the United States and getting rid of a cap on tuition fees all together. This would mean that, like the United States, each university would be able to dictate their own tuition fees, and that the government would no longer have to fund the large portion of higher education costs that they currently do.
Franklin D Roosevelt once made clear that “Education is the last expenditure on which America should be willing to economize”; sadly though, Roosevelt realised the importance of education and its universal accessibility but the masses did not. This is evident from the prevailing attitude toward university education in the United States, where private universities can charge whatever they like. The cost of tuition at Harvard this academic year is $32,557 (or approximately £20,198). Meanwhile, less reputable universities such as Highlands University in New Mexico cost $4,052 at most (approximately £2,500).
Giving universities the freedom to dictate their own cost leads to the possibility of the more highly regarded universities being able to charge up to fifteen times more per year. This means that many students who are highly capable and have the right grades to attend a more reputable university are unable to do so due to being financially incapable. This undoubtedly can have a knock-on effect in later life, as those who go to the better thought-of universities usually end up with higher profile, better paying jobs. If it is only the wealthy who can afford this education, then those will be the individuals getting these jobs, keeping the rich people rich and the poor people poor. The establishment of financial aid and scholarships aim to bridge any margins created by this huge difference in cost between various universities, but many individuals fall through the gaps or are not considered eligible for this support.
If the UK were to shift toward this model for higher education, we would likely see a similar trend; an elitist education system, growing wealth discrepancies, and increased individualism.
A far more appealing model of higher education is that of Norway, where there are no actual tuition fees and only a small cost of ÂŁ40 per term that goes toward funding gyms, canteens and student societies. Students receive a loan of ÂŁ8,000 per year to go towards covering the cost of books, rent and food, which can potentially become a non-repayable scholarship based on the academic performance of each student. Despite this, many students still choose to work part time in order to have a more active social life. To have the choice of whether to work or not, however, is a luxury that would not be feasible for many in the UK were the tuition fees to rise any more than their current cost, and there are worries about the negative impact that regular work hours could have on results.
One of the most important aspects of living away from home whilst at university is the opportunities to try out new things. This can include courses in Nordic literature, which may have little or no benefit in later life but are intellectually stimulating. Student life is about stimulation in a variety of ways; expanding social circles, learning to drink sensibly (or just learning to drink), paying bills, trying out new activities (through societies or in one’s own time), learning instruments, and having parties. Imposing even higher fees than those already in existence will draw away from the importance of the passion to learn and put more emphasis on the misconception that university is only about academic achievements, getting a high-income job and paying off that student loan. Right now we have three years in which to forget those pressures and simply learn in whichever way suits us.
Though getting rid of the cap on tuition fees may possibly equate to lower taxation, surely it is preferable to have a system in which we all contribute and from which we all have the possibility of benefitting, regardless of income. If someone actually has the desire to pursue their education and learn, it is in the best interests of all society to support and nourish that desire…every time.
