Britain’s only neoconservative? – Interview

Douglas Murray is the director of the Centre for Social Cohesion and the author of ‘Neoconservatism: why we need it’. Having advised the Rudy Giuliani campaign on foreign policy, he visited Durham to make the case for John McCain at the Union Society. But first he talked to Palatinate about religion, America, war and what it is to be a neocon.  Interview by Chris Wright.

What does it mean to be a neoconservative?

I’m often described as Britain’s only neocon, but that’s not entirely true – Mr Blair is still mainly on these shores – but yes, I am myself a confessed neoconservative. It’s a very much misunderstood mindset. Neoconservatives tend to be thought of, when they’re thought of at all, as hawks, ultra-right conservatives or something like that. Actually, this is a long way from the truth. Neoconservatives were always described in their first generation as liberals who had been mugged by reality. They were left-wingers who migrated onto the conservative side. This hadn’t had much of a British presence until, I’d argue, the 1990s or so – when a number of people in this country who were erstwhile left-wingers migrated rightwards. […] But a lot of people actually in Britain – and I count myself among them – found the experience of the Balkans in the 1990s the thing that woke us up: a genuine sense of horror, amazement and shame that a genocide could take place on European soil – again! – and the international community did nothing, and could do nothing.

Did you start on the left?

No. Well…this is a point of some contention. I once joked to a newspaper that if I had spent any time on the left it was a matter of hours. I did myself a disservice in that! I regard myself as coming from a left-wing, liberal – in the British sense of the term – mindset. I believe in progressive rights, obviously in gay rights, women’s rights, and equality of all kinds – things that conservatives have tended to at least withhold judgement on. Coming from a left-wing perspective, as it were, you start to see where the left breaks down, your liberal bones begin to crack; it happens bit by bit. Famously, with a lot of us, it comes because of extremist Islam. You can tolerate different mindsets, every imaginable kind of religion, and every manifestation of a religion – but what do you do when your tolerance of religious minorities rubs up against your beliefs in progressive rights for other minorities?

Aren’t neocons typically socially conservative, for instance, on sexuality?

It’s very interesting you say that. I’m not sure the people using those kinds of terms [‘sodomy’] would be categorised as neocons. It’s very true that Alan Bloom, who is thought to have died of AIDS – almost certainly did […] I think there were certain people who thought it better not to mention that. […] There’s a woman called Midge Decter, married to Norman Podhoretz, who has just contributed to a magazine that I write for – Standpoint – this month. Midge Decter has expressed extremely unpleasant views about homosexuals. Myself, I’ve never hidden being gay and I’ve never found it a problem politically, or found anything very interesting in it. I would say that there has been – there is an element – there is a school, as it were, of people for whom it is probably just a generational embarrassment, I’d say. Among my generation I don’t think there’s much problem about it. […] A gay Republican friend of mine in Washington when I was over there recently said to me, you know, it’s only the gays who are fighting the Islamists, it seems at times. That’s not entirely true, but I mean – and I stress Islamists, there – my great political hero is Pim Fortuyn, who woke up a lot of people I think to this, and other people doing this, people like Bruce Bawer, the American writer now living in Norway, and elsewhere – there’s a very interesting new play at the Royal Court by Christopher Shinn, the gay American playwright, called ‘Now or Later’, about the son of a presidential candidate – his father’s elected president – who is found on the night of the election to have photos taken of him crashing a naked pub dressed as Mohamed. It’s a very, very good play, in which Christopher Shin really opens up the liberal mindset and where it breaks down on this issue.

What is the neocon critique of relativism?

Relativism comes from a perfectly acceptable and understandable point, which is the belief that in order to understand other people you have to understand their mindset, which of course has a very, very good basis in race politics and so on. Where you have a problem – and this of course is what Bloom exposed in the educational field – is when you are so open-minded you effectively have a closed mind. When the open mind tips into nihilism, because, aware that everything has a point, you suddenly realise that nothing has a point. Nihilism is the only endpoint of this. And although there are not very many nihilists in the world, there are a very large number of relativists. Bloom, as you know, opens The Closing of the American Mind by saying that one things is certain on any university campus, that each year students will come up with the belief that there is no such thing as truth.

Now, most of us don’t believe in dogmatic, certainly not inarguable assertions of truth. As a believer in secularism I find that anyone who ever comes towards me claiming that their book says, or an archangel once told their guy that, something is the case – this is the worst grounding on which to base something. But the problem is that when you move away from religiously based orders of society, you have to still have some kind of grip points, you still have to have points which people know to be true, which are true. Certainly realms beyond which you will not be taken. It’s very hard to assert that, certainly in post-religious societies, especially the one we inhabit. But something has to be put in place, or something has to be shored up, because otherwise the end result I think is a sort of pandemonium.

But you personally are no longer religious?

I find myself not a believer any more, since I wrote [‘Neoconservatism: why we need it’]. I mean, it’s for personal reasons, but I’ve been joking that Mohamed made me an atheist, which is true. When you spend too much time focusing on one religion, you know, it’s harder and harder to say, I don’t think that your guy heard voices but someone else did. I don’t believe that anyone hears voices. But a religious basis for society is something different. My own ideal society, as you can probably intimate from my writing, is America. And the reason why is in particular the founding fathers – the amazing recognition they made that the church and religions have a very important place in the marketplace of ideas, but that they will not dictate the law. I think the most moving editing job ever done was in the founding documents of the American state, where Mr Jefferson argues that you don’t need the phrase “We believe these truths to be dictated by God” – that all men are created equal. We don’t need any of that. “We believe these truths to be self-evident” – much, much more powerful.

Does that make religion a Straussian ‘noble lie’?

No, this is not a noble lie. This would be to say that we would not want a situation to emerge where, for instance, British school children were ignorant of their own history and culture. I’ve just been trying to finish on the train an essay I’m writing for a new volume which the editor of the Spectator and the Prime Minister are putting together on Britishness, and in my contribution I want to say that, you know, if somebody is not educated in the Christian faith, huge chunks of our literature, our art, are utterly meaningless. Walking through the National Gallery – the annunciation, the ascension, they’re all the same. It would become like trying to understand what was going on in paintings of Greek myths when you’ve never come across them. It would be an utterly alienating experience. Now the multicultural disaster – and by that I mean multiculturalism as ghettoization, not multi-racialism or pluralism, which most of us are for – has led to a situation where people do pretend we’re starting at year zero, where you can celebrate every culture other than our own. And I think that has, and will continue to lead to a great amount of upset, alienation and isolation.

What is a neocon foreign policy advising today?

I think that for the next few years, there are three main theatres of operations – the first is Iraq. Mr McCain, as I’ll say tonight, has got one of the great tragedies in politics, which is to say that he’s got what he wanted. Iraq is now pretty much on the right track, at least, if not perfect – there will never be a day of victory, there will only be a day when the state is closer to being itself than it ever was before. So Iraq is to a great extent off the map. I haven’t been there for a year, not since the first few weeks of the surge. Now, Afghanistan, the big issue seems to me to be whether or not this becomes an Afghan-Pakistan border conflict. I suspect that’s something Mr Obama will be far more vulnerable to creating than Mr McCain. I think the temptation for Mr Obama in his first few months to assert himself and show himself to be strong will be pretty prevalent. I would cite that in my own mind, and in the mind of most of my ideological comrades, if you will, that the main question is not Afghanistan. Afghanistan, to a great extent – and I don’t want to sound glib about this – the mission itself was accomplished very swiftly, and the mission remains accomplished. Afghanistan is not, will not be, a place where people can go to bases and train for attacks in London, New York, Washington, and so on. That’s done. The question about building Afghanistan is a separate one. It strikes me that Iraq was a reconstruction project and Afghanistan was a construction project. Finding a viable economic solution in Afghanistan is not going to be easy – it may not even be possible.

The thing, as you probably know, which has been exercising people like me most for some years, is Iran. Because Iran as a centre of instability in the region, as the funder of Hamas and Hezbollah, the armer of terrorist organisations, the murderer of many of our troops in Southern Iraq – on top of all this we see continuing, and it looks like unstopping, attempts by Iran to acquire nuclear capability. I think this is the single question which should, and will, most exercise the next US administration – whoever is in charge. The decision has to be taken between a bad decision and a worse one. The bad decision is whether or not you are willing ultimately to strike Iran, which I think will have to happen. The worse decision is that Iran will become a nuclear power with the most insane regime of modern times in charge. And whether or not you allow that to happen and the follow-on effect, which is that every other country in the region will also acquire nuclear capability. This seems to me to be bequeathing the next generation a world where a nuclear exchange is very, very likely, and I don’t think we can allow that to happen.