Shakespeare Recovered: the mystifying story of Durham’s First Folio
By Jasmine Davey
From theft to recovery, the story of Durham’s First Folio takes centre stage in Palace Green Library’s new exhibition, ‘Shakespeare Recovered’.
Durham has been the proud owner of its edition since the 1620s, when it was purchased by Bishop John Cosin. Published in 1623, the Folio contains 36 plays, 18 of which would otherwise not have survived, such as Macbeth. Durham’s Folio is one of 235 surviving copies.
The Folio was mainly reserved for research purposes until 1998, when it was displayed in Cosin’s Library. It was stolen later that year. It is understood that the thief simply walked into the library, unscrewed the case it was displayed behind, and hid it in his briefcase. The Folio would not be seen for another ten years.
In 2008, an antiques dealer entered the Folger Library in Washington DC to request authentication on a book he’d supposedly found at a friend’s house in Cuba. Library staff were immediately suspicious, and soon established it to be Durham’s missing copy. It was returned to Durham in 2010.
The book was in poor condition. Its cover and spine were missing, and some of its pages had become detached. However, experts could still identify it as Durham’s missing Folio by examining its more distinctive features, many of which were unique to this copy. The exhibition highlights some of these elements, which range from creases and dents to free-drawn margin lines and handwritten notes.

The covers and spine are suspected to have been deliberately removed by the thief to make the Folio unidentifiable. Although the thief has never officially been confirmed, it is strongly suspected to be antiques dealer Raymond Scott, from County Durham – the same dealer who brought the Folio to Washington DC. Scott was known to live beyond his means, driving a Ferrari and indulging in expensive liquor, despite living with his mother in a council estate. It is assumed that Scott stole the Folio to boost his finances; a similar folio sold for $10M USD in 2020.
Scott never admitted to originally stealing the Folio, yet was charged with handling stolen goods and removing stolen property from the UK. He committed suicide in 2013 whilst in prison.

The ‘Shakespeare Recovered’ exhibition focuses on a key debate: should the Folio be rebound? Whilst some claim it is important to retain the historical integrity of the book, others argue that rebinding would better preserve it for future generations. This would also not be the first time the Folio was rebound; the covers had previously been replaced in the 19th century.
Despite the ongoing debate, Palace Green Library has decided to maintain the Folio in its current state. In the exhibition, the Library states “rebinding our Folio would irreversibly remove much of what makes it exceptional. We believe that we can learn more about it from its current condition than we could if it were rebound as any other book on the shelf”.
Whilst keeping the book unbound does leave it in a more delicate form, Palace Green asserted that “the fragility that stops us reading our Folio as a traditional book presents opportunities for learning and research that no other First Folio can provide”.
The exhibition comes amid a wave of new research fuelled by technological advancement. For instance, a process named ‘spectroscopy’ is used to uncover hidden details such as ink marks, creases, and materials within the paper. This involves electromagnetic waves being targeted at the book, with specialised detectors being able to capture the effects.
In addition to ‘Shakespeare Recovered’, Palace Green Library is currently hosting the ‘Binding the Bard’ exhibition, which displays the entrants to its international bookbinding competition. The contest invited binders to submit a design for a modern reproduction of the book, the best of which are included in the exhibit.

The Folio is on display until 7th September and is free to visit at Palace Green Library. The exhibition includes a 5 minute documentary-style video, access to the folio, information on the current research, and the opportunity for questions with a member of staff
Featured image: Jasmine Davey

