Samira Ahmed’s victory: what her case against the BBC says about equality in the media

By Patrick Digby

On January 10th 2020, Samira Ahmed won her discrimination case against the BBC at the London Central Employment Tribunal. Mrs. Ahmed’s lawyers successfully argued that her work on ‘Newswatch’ was sufficiently similar to that done by Jeremy Vine on “Points of View” between 2008 and 2018, and as such, she is entitled to be paid the same as him. Mr. Vine was paid £3,000 per episode for Points of View as opposed to the £440 per episode that Mrs. Ahmed is paid for Newswatch.

This is the latest blow to the BBC, which has been plagued by a series of scandals in recent years, including criticism relating to the gender pay gap revealed when it published lists of all those earning over £150,000 a year. In that episode, Carrie Gracie, then China editor for the BBC resigned, after learning she earned less than the male Middle East and North America editors Jeremy Bowen and Jon Sopel, respectively. Ms. Gracie took to Twitter to say she “could not be more proud” of Mrs. Ahmed after the verdict was announced.

The larger implications of this ruling are yet to be seen, but it is clear that it is an incredibly important ruling for women working at the BBC and in UK media generally. The BBC should take a conciliatory approach and settle any similar cases quickly, generously and quietly, if it wants to move on and come out of this case with minimal reputational damage. Whether they will do so is anyone’s guess. The BBC is also in the crosshairs of Downing Street due to Boris Johnson’s refusal to be interviewed by Andrew Neil, with the government reportedly wanting to scrap the license fee.

The larger implications of this ruling are yet to be seen

Therefore, it is going to need every bit of public support it can get to weather the coming storm. As for women in the media, this judgment is undoubtedly a big step forward, giving hope to the 20 or so other cases that the National Union of Journalists said are in the works against the BBC regarding unequal pay. In a wider sense, it a positive move towards truly equal pay between genders, for which the UK currently stands at 15th in the world, according to the World Economic Forum. Mrs. Ahmed will continue to host Newswatch.

Photo credit: Paul Jenkins via Flickr