India’s political climate under Modi’s reign: tumultuous and divided
By Patrick Digby
Even by India’s high standards, the political climate in the world’s largest democracy is currently tumultuous. On December 9th, the governing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), led by Narendra Modi, introduced the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) which duly passed through both houses in two days; quicker than its dissenters could say “lack of legislative oversight”.
The CAA has been presented by the BJP as a humanitarian law that gives refuge to persecuted minorities by allowing them Indian citizenship. However, opponents have highlighted many flaws in the law and the stated reasons behind it. Firstly, the CAA only applies to migrants who have been in India since 2014, have fled from either Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Pakistan and who are members of one of these religions; Hinduism, Buddhism, Christianity, Sikhism, Jainism, and Zoroastrianism. Therefore, the CAA has created a religious criterion in a path to Indian citizenship, which not only deliberately persecutes Muslims by omission (despite Islam being India’s second-largest religion with approximately 200 million followers) but also clearly violates India’s secular constitution. As such, the law has been denounced by, amongst many others, the UN Human Rights Office, the EU’s ambassador to India and the US Commission on International Religious Freedom.
the political climate in the world’s largest democracy is currently tumultuous
This latest controversy comes as part of a pattern of rising Hindu nationalism and aggression towards Muslims that includes the abolition of the special status granted to Muslim-majority Jammu and Kashmir for the last 70 years, in August 2019. The area is now under direct control from Delhi, which has packed it with troops who have placed its political leaders under house arrest and cut off the internet.
The reaction to the CAA has been unprecedentedly strong, with the submission to the Supreme Court of 60 petitions to annul the law and widespread protests/ counter-protests over the last few weeks, some of which have been violent. In a particularly nasty incident on January 5th at Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU), a hotbed of opposition to the BJP, 34 teachers and students who oppose the CAA were attacked by masked intruders, aided by police. Incidents like this are likely to continue.
It is clear to all that Mr. Modi has been emboldened by his landslide majority in May 2019. However, the protests he has unleashed across the country with the CAA are likely to, at least for the time being, seriously dent his popularity and reputation. He should tread more carefully, if he wants a third term.
Photo Credit: G20 Argentina via Creative Commons
