River Doce dam disaster affects us all

By William Parsons

Last month Brazil faced an environmental catastrophe. Thick, toxic mud washed down the River Doce after a wastewater dam collapsed near Bento Rodrigues (450 kilometres north of Rio de Janeiro), exterminating wildlife and polluting the drinking water of hundreds of thousands of people. After being released on November 5th, the sea of mud finally reached the Atlantic two weeks later, killing marine life, and imperilling a nature reserve which is a vital breeding ground for the endangered leatherback turtle.

The worst part of this disaster is not just that it is – and will continue to be – so utterly destructive to the coast and to wildlife along the 400-mile stretch of the River Doce but that the catastrophe could have been evaded. Concerns over the dam’s structural integrity were raised as early as 2013, when the dam’s operators – a joint venture between mining giants BHP Billiton and Vale – were allowed by regulators to raise its height. The storage of thousands of tons of poisonous waste behind a dam initially made the project a hazardous one, yet to exacerbate matters it was also positioned above a river valley with a clear path across fresh water sources and biodiverse forests all the way to the sea.

The truth is, this is but one instance in a long history of disasters, which point to one undeniable fact – the pursuit of economic gain by large, wealthy corporations is ruining our planet’s environment. People have known this for years now, and the disaster in Brazil indicates yet again that serious, consistent regulation is needed if we are to have any hope of preserving biodiversity worldwide.

There have been so many man-made environmental disasters in the past thirty years – like the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil-spill which killed at least 100,000 seabirds and over 2,000 sea otters, or the 2000 Baia Mare cyanide spill in Romania which caused the deaths of thousands of fish – that it becomes clear that there is a trend of economic exploitation of our environmental resources. Yet these, as with the dam in Brazil, are just isolated incidents: ‘accidents’ brought about by negligence and lax control.

Consider also the purposeful, deliberate destruction of biodiversity across the world which has occurred over the past century, and is reaching fever pitch now. The earth is increasingly raked and churned by a growing surface mining industry; pollutants from factories in China are pumped into water sources, poisoning wildlife and reducing the amount of drinkable water; and deforestation continues to destroy rich rainforests across the globe. Just in the past few months, vast forest fires ravaged the rainforests of Indonesia, burning across protected habitats of endangered creatures. In those months, Indonesia became the biggest worldwide emitter of carbon dioxide, and, worryingly, many of these fires were started by wood pulp companies and smallholders to clear land for cultivation. One of the worst fires of all was within land owned by Asia Pulp and Paper. Massive environmental devastation was purposefully enacted as a means of increasing production and profit.

The natural world will not be protected so long as companies like BHP Billiton or Asia Pulp and Paper are not brought to heal the damage they have done. Individual actions like recycling your bottles and cans, or switching off lights when they’re not in use, mean absolutely nothing if companies with the power to crush biodiversity are at liberty to do so. It’s not enough to rely on companies to act responsibly – clearly many are incapable of this.

If we are to have any hope of protecting biodiversity worldwide, governments must take the threat posed by such companies seriously. Certainly, not every government has the power to control companies and adequately protect the environment, but this is why international cooperation is so important. Meaningful cooperation to control the actions of companies and establish protective measures on a worldwide scale might be an onerous task, but it is far less onerous than the alternative; changing the attitudes and wants of billions of people to reduce the pressure on the earth’s resources.

The environment and its many ecosystems are being altered on a radical, unprecedented scale to the detriment not only of biodiversity, but the security of humankind. We often seem certain that the continuation of the human race is safe no matter the hardship, but it is not. Recent events in Brazil can serve as our wake up call. We have the tools to avert irreversible disaster, and they must be used.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are not representative of Palatinate, and are those of the author only. If you disagree with the opinions expressed, or would like to write for Palatinate in response, please contact the Politics Section at politics@palatinate.org.uk

Photograph: NASA, High Contrast via Wikimedia Commons