Rishi Sunak: the face of fiscal sanity?

By Rohan Lal

Rishi Sunak, the Chancellor, will walk a fiscal tightrope in the coming months. Estimates suggest that spending pressures in social care, health, and education will push the total spent during the pandemic beyond £500 billion by the end of 2021. In order to balance the books, tax rises and cuts in other areas seem inevitable. This is likely to bring Mr Sunak into conflict with a Conservative government of spendthrifts. 

By nature, Boris Johnson, the Prime Minister, is more a casino gambler than deficit hawk. Mr Johnson recently paid an estimated £200,000 for the refurbishment of his flat at No.11 Downing Street. Lavish items included £840-a-roll gold wallpaper, a £20,000 sofa, and an £11,600 owl lantern. The Prime Minister is also often associated with grand public infrastructure projects. Last year, Mr Johnson championed the ‘HS2 Railroad Plan’, a new rail link between London and the Midlands, which is expected to cost more than £130 billion. More recently, the Prime Minister proposed plans for the “Boris Burrow”, a planned tunnel between Scotland and Northern Ireland, which could cost an additional £33 billion.

Boris Johnson, the prime minister, is more a casino gambler than deficit hawk

Mr Johnson’s new so-called ‘red wall’ voters also are not the most fiscally conservative constituency. The promise of “levelling up” has raised hopes of increased public investment in northern areas. The construction of a new coal mine in Cumbria, the emergence of a National Infrastructure Bank in Leeds, and the establishment of a Northern Treasury in Darlington reflect a pivot in fiscal focus towards under-represented areas in the North. The Prime Minister is unlikely to support public spending cuts and increases in taxation, despite the debt implications of the pandemic.

It is the job of Mr Sunak to prevent Mr Johnson from delving further into the government’s piggybank. Back in November last year, speaking to Sky News, Mr Sunak said he may have to take the Prime Minister’s “credit card away”.

As of 2021, the Chancellor has begun to urge fiscal restraint. This month, Mr Johnson reneged on a manifesto promise (to the dismay of Tory rebels) by sponsoring the Treasury’s proposed cuts to international aid. A decrease in the foreign aid budget will save the government £4 billion. The government is also likely to opt out of the “triple lock” on pensions. Pensions ought to rise in conjunction with a post-pandemic rise in earnings. However, an uprate in pensions will cost the government another £3 billion. It is unlikely that Mr Sunak will favour yet more spending at the moment.

As the pandemic’s impact on society loosens, the cause of fiscal conservatism will come to dominate the national agenda

Taxes are also likely to rise in the post-pandemic era. In this year’s March Budget, the Chancellor has already committed to raising corporation tax to 25% on company profits over £250,000 by 2023. The first corporation tax rise since 1974 will generate an estimated £48 billion by 2026. In 2019, Mr Johnson pledged to check rises in Income Tax, National Insurance, and VAT. However, the Treasury is also expected to raise National Insurance contributions by 1% to fund England’s creaking social care system. Pre-pandemic pledges appear to have become post-pandemic fictions due to the budgetary pressures mounting on the government.

As the pandemic’s impact on society loosens, the cause of fiscal conservatism will come to dominate the national agenda. At the heart of the government, a financially conscious chancellor will look to keep the government’s treasure chest under lock-and-key. Tensions between No.10 and No.11 are likely to increase as the deficit spending of the pandemic era is reversed and a new age of austerity becomes the politics of the future.

Image: UK Prime Minister via Creative Commons