Ride a Black Swan
by Adam Seddon
Black Swan charts the struggle of Nina (Natalie Portman), an introverted and disciplined ballerina that has just won a starring role: the swan queen. She must play both the white and black swans. The former is perfectly suited to her: beautiful, fragile, and inhibited. The latter requires her to embrace everything she has spent a lifetime suppressing: sexuality, ambition, appetite unchecked by fear. This, combined with a punishing physical regime and habitual bulimia, becomes a recipe for mental breakdown. Her closest rival – Lily – appears to possess the perfect lacklustre enthusiasm to play the black swan, and she soon emerges as an aggressive rival. But the film is an unreliable witness. The story takes place inside Nina’s mind, and her competitor’s possession of the black swan’s menace soon gives way to a confrontation with the dark underside of herself.
This film has unusual courage. In the hands of a lesser director it would play like a cautionary tale of ambition leading a good girl into a lifestyle of visceral self-harm and emotional alienation from her mother. The pressure of becoming something she is not would be easily handled as a warning against over-reaching and yet another fatuous comment on the image pressures of being a woman in a modern media climate. But Aronofsky does not do this. The bulimia is not painted as a sickening habit practised by a poor young thing. It is a gruelling element of a gruelling regime, not unlike the crunching pressure exerted on her cracking toenails whilst en pointe. It is routine, not melodramatic, and we are not invited to be scandalised.
So too with Thomas, the sexually aggressive director of the ballet company. His lecherous advances would swiftly give way to caricature were they not carefully tempered by Nina’s hesitant but urgent reciprocation, gradually thawing her resistance as she comes to embrace her emerging nature. This journey has to end in violence, but it is a violent birth into freedom from the smothering over-care of her mother and the eerily prepubescent lifestyle she shares with her (complete with teddies and ballet music-boxes).
Black Swan challenges you to understand Nina’s journey from the inside, and to share in her vision of the descent into insanity and mental breakdown as a struggle upwards, toward the dark majestic heights of artistic perfection.

