My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding: “It’s not tribal Afghanistan, it’s contemporary Britain”
It’s a world where girls leave school as young as 11 to cook and clean, care for younger siblings, and wait the few short years before they themselves get married. They’ll then be answerable to a husband who must dominate his wife for fear of “not being – in the eyes of the community – a man”, and without whose permission they cannot even leave the home. It’s not tribal Afghanistan, it’s contemporary Britain, and if Channel 4 is to be believed, this is what life is like for Irish travellers everywhere.
‘My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding’ lured most of us in with the sheer visual spectacle of these extraordinary ceremonies. 5 stone wedding dresses drowning in glitter, sequins and jewels; young brides staggering up the aisle ornamented with mechanical butterflies and LED lights, hardly able to step out of the wedding limo or sit down at top table. The queasy voyeurism of watching young girls dressed like ‘80s showgirls is a little troubling, but our concerns are easily shrugged off in favour of gawping at the next cheap delight: a six-year-old with a spray tan, or the groom wearing a vest to cut the cake. With viewing figures of 8 million (the highest since Big Brother) it seems that Cutting Edge has struck television gold. Like the gruesome wreckage of a car crash, it’s almost impossible to look away.
Beneath the frothy, fabulous facade, however, we cannot fail to notice darker hints. The practice of ‘grabbing’, whereby men drag off young women because, as one man puts it, “girls won’t give you a kiss; you’ve got to beat them first” looks alarmingly violent. Our fears aren’t exactly allayed by comments like: “I don’t think the girl would enjoy the grab”, or one recipient, Cheyenne, saying quietly afterwards that “it’s not nice, not nice at all. But you’ve got to get used to it”.
Cutting Edge’s voice-over, dripping with self-satisfied political correctness, reminds us that this is a community which is “desperately clawing at a traditional way of life”, resisting the corrupting influence of modern Western lifestyles. Yet it is unclear whether we should sympathise with old-fashioned dictates, for instance, that women not drink alcohol or spend time alone with a man before marriage, when the same codes fail spectacularly to apply to men. Laughing, idling, drinking (and, to confirm all our favourite stereotypes, doing most of these in their ‘wife-beater’ vests) the difference in gender roles could hardly be starker. Men enjoy considerable freedoms, while it’s their “mammy or sister” who cleans the caravan each day. We see girls enjoying a Cinderella –style wedding, only to carry on mopping and dusting afterwards. As more than one female traveller says, “it’s a man’s world”.
Just what is it about these practices – which we would openly condemn, were we watching a sober exposé of life in Pakistan, Somalia or Iran- that we find so easy to bear? Why, because of their spectacular embrace of gaudy dresses and lascivious dance moves, do we call it ‘brilliant TV’ and just move on?
Perhaps it’s because everybody seems to be having such a good time. Wearing ferocious amounts of make-up, gyrating (apparently) like Shakira and avowing that finding a husband is the most important thing a traveller girl can ever do, a lot of these young women seem to be having the time of their lives.
Channel 4’s editors have, in all likelihood, edited the programme ruthlessly. Perhaps we see only the more outrageous responses, such as the man who declares that, “yeah”, he does “own” his wife. The dress-maker Thelma, for instance, features heavily, offering her observations like some omniscient pundit whose word is truth. She tells us, for instance, that around 50% of traveller wives will experience domestic abuse, frequently “[blaming] themselves” or seeing it as “a fact of life”. Believable, perhaps. But enough evidence to decry a whole community?
The programme’s scope is narrow, and given that we meet just one figure who even speaks of abuse (a survivor who, unusually for a traveller, divorced her husband), it’s difficult to know where to begin in forming our opinions. In the best tradition of easy-watching, weeknight TV, we are offered some pretty simple dichotomies (and with the words ‘Big Fat…’ in the title, this should come as no surprise).
It is predictable, then, that Irish travellers and Romany gypsies have formally complained to OFCOM for the “cheap, nasty media exploitation of [their] communities”. I’m reminded of David Cameron’s rather insubstantial comments last week that “multiculturalism has failed” but that we should all try to get along with one another in spite of our differences. If our media were a little less racist, less prone to holding up whole communities for derision and disapproval, then it might happen. The only reason it won’t? That if a TV channel ever felt like producing an even-handed portrayal of the traveller community…we’d ditch it in a moment, and watch ‘The Only Way is Essex’ instead.

