Revisiting Cowboy Carter in the Wake of its Grammy Wins

“I ain’t no regular singer, now come get everything you came for’”

There is perhaps no better line to metonymise Cowboy Carter than the above. Responsible for winning Beyoncé both Best Country Album and the coveted Album of the Year at the 2025 GRAMMYs, Cowboy Carter is a sweeping masterclass in musical artistry. It is a country album, yes, but it is also a challenge: to the Recording Academy, the gatekeepers of country music, and the deeply-embedded roots of American racism. In revisiting this album, I want to answer the question everyone is asking online right now: did Cowboy Carter deserve Album of the Year?

I’ll start with a brief history lesson to underscore the significance of this album’s concept: Beyoncé allegedly came up with the idea after her performance at the 2016 Country Music Awards in which she sang ‘Daddy Lessons’ with The Chicks. Her performance received backlash from angry country music fans who claimed she wasn’t ‘true country’ enough to perform at the award ceremony. Of course, the criticism, coming in the form of online hate comments, was thinly veiled racism: how dare a black female pop star intrude on the sacred white land of country music? (These gatekeepers conveniently forget that country music was originated by enslaved Black people in the South.)

In response to the attacks on her artistry and identity, Beyoncé stood her ground. She dedicated herself to creating an entire country album, including doing research on the genre. Rolling Stone perfectly described Cowboy Carter as a ‘dissertation.’ She was saying, ‘You want country? I’ll show you country.’

This album is insanely layered, from musical references to pieces of history embedded in the folds of the lyrics, not to mention its gorgeous vocal soundscape. The first three songs, in my opinion, act as pillars of the album. The first, ‘AMERIICAN REQUIEM,’ is a sweeping track that critiques the cyclical nature of racism in America and establishes the boundary-breaking goals of the album. Second, ‘BLACKBIIRD’ covers The Beatles’ song of the same name and features four young Black female country artists. It is a gorgeous rendition that reclaims the song’s original meaning by centering the voices of the Black women for whom it was written. ‘16 CARRIAGES’ is the third song on Cowboy Carter and details Beyoncé’s journey growing up in the music industry. I call these songs ‘pillars’ because they all address key facets of the album: ‘AMERIICAN REQUIEM’ is for America, ‘BLACKBIIRD’ is for other Black female artists, and ‘16 CARRIAGES’ is for Beyoncé herself.

This album is insanely layered, from musical references to pieces of history embedded in the folds of the lyrics, not to mention its gorgeous vocal soundscape

Throughout Cowboy Carter are sound bites from country legends Dolly Parton, Willie Nelson, and Linda Martell, their voices like stamps of approval on Beyoncé’s project. These artists are also there to remind everyone that genre is only what you make of it — and country was made great by the people who pushed the boundaries.

I want to stress that I am not an avid fan of country music (although I’m more partial to female country artists). It feels, to me at least, like so much of mainstream country right now is watered-down slop about beer and trucks, which is why Cowboy Carter stands out in the way it does. Beyoncé brings the genre back to themes of identity, resilience, and reconnecting with your roots. 

All of that said, not every song is a political anthem (nor should they need to be). Some, like ‘LEVII’S JEANS’ and ‘BODYGUARD,’ sit back and bask in their country soundscape, taking on more fun themes like love and lust. Even amid the more complex, intellectual threads of the album, there are still easily digestible, plain fun moments.

Now, this is undoubtedly a country album, but it would be a disrespect to the art to reduce it to just a country album. In a spoken intro, Linda Martell slyly murmurs, “Genres are a funny little concept, aren’t they? In theory, they have a simple definition that’s easy to understand. But in practice, well, some may feel confined.” The statement is followed by the explosive, gun-slinging rap that is ‘SPAGHETTII.’ Yet rather than detract from the thesis of Cowboy Carter as a country album, the genre deviation only widens its scope. Beyoncé is not trying to slot herself neatly into country music; she is taking country music and making it thoroughly Beyoncé. And part of what makes this album so incredible is that it still manages to feel cohesive, despite drawing from rap, pop, house, and even a brief foray into opera, as well as pure country. Cowboy Carter doesn’t just challenge country, it challenges genre itself.

Beyoncé is not trying to slot herself neatly into country music; she is taking country music and making it thoroughly Beyoncé.

Because this is more of a think piece than an album review, I want to discuss Beyoncé Bowl, because it’s a crucial thread in the tapestry of Cowboy Carter, especially when talking about its GRAMMY wins. On December 25th, Beyoncé performed at halftime during NFL Christmas Gameday in her hometown of Houston, Texas. It was the first Christmas Day halftime show as well as the first time she played Cowboy Carter live. (If you haven’t seen it, go watch it now — it’s a fantastic use of fifteen minutes.) With six featured guests, dozens of backup dancers, an actual horse, and a whopping ten songs, Beyoncé Bowl is a foot-stomping explosion of glittery red, white, and blue. If her 2016 CMAs performance is a hesitant foray into the world of country music, Beyoncé Bowl takes a jewel-studded cowboy hat and crowns her as its queen.

The performance, while also used to tease an upcoming tour, was in my opinion the final boost she needed to win the GRAMMYs. The costumes, dancing, and Beyoncé’s unflinching starpower made the whole thing feel distinctly American, which is why it’s such a powerful performance and album. She is rejecting the racist American institution that held her down while simultaneously embracing her geographic roots as a source of pride — American requiem indeed. Beyoncé’s ability to let resistance and patriotism coexist in her art is incredibly refreshing, and so important in a time when many Americans (including myself) are trying to grapple with a national identity that gets increasingly more selective about who deserves to belong.

She is rejecting the racist American institution that held her down while simultaneously embracing her geographic roots as a source of pride

So, to return to the question I posed at the beginning: did Cowboy Carter deserve Album of the Year? The short answer is yes, obviously. The album, while a fantastic work of music alone, is so much more than just the music. It takes a great musician to write great songs, but it takes a great storyteller to create art that goes beyond a listening experience. Beyoncé is both — and on top of it all, one of the best performers in the world right now.

It was disappointing to go online after the GRAMMYs and see people contesting her win, attributing it to DEI or Jay-Z’s speech at last year’s awards. But in my opinion, those people either didn’t listen to the album or didn’t understand what she was doing. Cowboy Carter is the Album of the Year, and I can bet that it’s only going to become more relevant as we progress through the next four years. This is the type of art we need right now.

Image credit: Kevin Winter/Getty Images for The Recording Academy