Review: Broadway’s Romeo and Juliet
By Lulu McDonald
Over winter break, I was lucky enough to see Romeo + Juliet on Broadway not once, but twice, while home in New York City. I had originally planned to just see it the first time, but the play, which could only be described as life-changing, begged itself to be rewatched. My second viewing only solidified my opinion of the show; that it is one of the best to ever grace Broadway’s stages.
I should begin with the perhaps embarrassing disclaimer that I have never read the original text of Romeo + Juliet. In an attempt to soothe those who would call me sacrilegious for reviewing a Shakespeare play I have never read, I will say that I am approaching this review as one of a unique play whose brilliance is elevated, not defined, by the acclaim of its original text. Therefore, I will not be analysing this production in relation to either the original play or other adaptations.
With that said, I want to start with staging. The show is performed in the round, with the main stage set directly in the middle of the theatre, surrounded on all sides by the audience. When audiences enter the theatre, the actors are already on stage, lounging around in costume and socializing with each other. Immediately the audience feels a sense of intimacy with the stage and the actors, as if we are walking into a story that is already happening, or spectators of a vibrant world existing only within the theatre.
The attention to detail in this production was something I kept coming back to
The stage is set with a grocery cart full of pastel-coloured teddy bears, which also decorate the merchandise stands and theatre bar (see my terrible picture of said bears). It’s jarring and weird, but not in a bad way. Instead, the teddies feel almost like an eerie symbol of the youthfulness running through Romeo + Juliet. They’re an unsettling symbol, almost morbid, considering how the play ends. There is also a giant gold cross at the far wall of the stage, most noticeable as the only source of light in the final scene of the play. It’s another unsettling symbol, undoubtedly an allusion to the religious imagery used throughout the play that enforces the feeling of Romeo and Juliet’s relationship as something divine.
The attention to detail in this production was something I kept coming back to after seeing it both times — from the costumes that look like an Urban Outfitters threw up on the stage, to the borg1 passed around by cast members throughout the show (cleverly reading ‘BORG-GIVE MY BROTHER’), the play felt decidedly young.
Of course it did: when stripped down to its bare Shakespearean bones, Romeo + Juliet is a story of two teenagers falling into a deep, life-changing love that is doomed by forces outside of their control — namely, the grudges and pride of adults. Regardless of how a director chooses to interpret it, this story is extremely relatable to the young people of today.
But even so, it’s clear that director Sam Gold and the rest of the creative team mined every bit of youth they could from the script and production (including, of course, the many classically Shakespearean sex jokes). Kit Connor plays Romeo as a headstrong, impulsive lover boy whose yearning feels distinctly childlike, and is complemented perfectly by Rachel Zegler’s Juliet. The West Side Story star has an effortless sweetness and, at the same time, the specific sense of maturity unique to teenage girls. The resulting effect? A relationship that feels very true to what it’s like being a teenager: feeling like everything matters so much, feeling disrespected by the adults in your life, that instinctual sense of rebellion. It sounds dumb, but the play truly spoke to my soul, and seeing it felt almost cathartic.
It’s clear that director Sam Gold and the rest of the creative team mined every bit of youth they could from the script and production
And clearly, the show is working. Never before have I been to a Broadway show that was so heavily populated with teenagers, and I’ve seen quite a few shows. Whether it’s a talented marketing team, the it-duo that is Kit Connor and Rachel Zegler, or a genuine excitement for Shakespeare (probably not this one), young people are drawn to this show.
I would be remiss if I didn’t discuss ‘Man of the House’, an original song written for the show by Grammy-winning producer Jack Antonoff (for those unfamiliar, he co-writes and produces for Taylor Swift, Lorde, and Lana Del Rey, among others). The ballad is sung by Juliet at the end of Act 1 and is an incredibly unique and important part of the show. It lets Juliet speak in modern words, telling us exactly how she feels: “You’re the man of the house to me”; “Without you I don’t know how to be”; “But if you came back now I’d take your namе”; “How does it feel to be God?”. Each of these lines point to specific, crucial fragments of Juliet’s psyche, equal parts interpretation and direct translation of the original text. Although I could write an entire essay on this song, I’ll keep it brief: ‘Man of the House’ is a puzzle piece of Romeo + Juliet that we didn’t know we were missing.
I cannot emphasize enough how detailed this production is — the directors truly left no stone unturned in putting it together. From the eerie, attention-grabbing set design to the frenetic yet emotional musical score, the final product that is Broadway’s Romeo + Juliet is one of the most moving, intense, and captivating shows I’ve ever witnessed, as well as by far my favourite adaptation of Shakespeare that I have yet to see. The show’s run ends in February but will not be forgotten by its fans.
Image credit: Ola Modelska

